3 ms·
> I think its better to just admit that freedoms / tech will always be misused by criminal actors, and that's just a price we agree to pay for privacy, security
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> I think its better to just admit that freedoms / tech will always be misused by criminal actors, and that's just a price we agree to pay for privacy, security, and liberty.
It's possible for both things to be true at the same time.
If Signal exists and is secure, will criminals use it? Sure they will, criminals are people and people want private communications.
But if you ban honest citizens from using Signal, will criminals stop using secure communications? No, they have an unusually strong incentive to use them and will seek out alternatives. The percentage of criminals who switch to insecure communications will be lower than the percentage of honest people who do.
Which increases the amount of crime, because the amount you're helping law enforcement catch criminals is smaller than the amount you're helping criminals exploit victims. This is also compounded by the fact that there are more honest people than criminals.
There is a theory of bureaucracy ("an institution will attempt to preserve the problem to which it is a solution") that says law enforcement agencies will ask for this even when they know full well that it will increase the overall amount of crime, because more crime is good for them since it means more law enforcement.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- null0pointer 7y agoI agree that criminals will use secure communications regardless of the law. I don't understand what you mean when you say it will increase crime though. Regardless, I feel like there's a deeper motive from governments/law enforcement. It would allow them to claim that anyone using secure comms must have something to hide and is thus a criminal. Combine that with mass surveillance and anyone you see sending encrypted traffic can automatically be assumed to be a criminal. I'm not saying this is right, it's certainly not right. But I'm sure that's the argument that will be used by those trying to push it. The only way to fix this is secure-by-default comms, such that all traffic looks the same and you cannot make any claims of criminality based on that alone.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> I don't understand what you mean when you say it will increase crime though. Suppose you're a criminal organization or a foreign government. You break into AT&T or Amazon or whomever and get access to a bunch of data streams. If they're all E2EE, you have a bunch of inscrutable ciphertext. If they're not, you have everybody's passwords, trade secrets, credit card numbers, information useful for blackmail etc. Lack of strong encryption enables crime -- that's why honest people use strong encryption.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoThis is also a good reason to use a VPN and tools like Tor, even when you have nothing to hide. The more normal it becomes the less likely it can be used as presumption of guilt or probable cause.
- Qub3d 7y ago> But if you ban honest citizens from using Signal, will criminals stop using secure communications? No, they have an unusually strong incentive to use them and will seek out alternatives. This has been a 2nd Amendment argument for ages: "If we outlaw guns, only outlaws will have guns."
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoIt has been a 2nd Amendment argument for ages because it's tautologically true. It correctly identifies that the proponents need to justify the cost from substantially all law-abiding citizens following the law against the benefit from only the law-abiding criminals following it. And say what you will about the benefits of law-abiding citizens carrying firearms, but if you want to seriously dispute the benefits of law-abiding citizens using encryption, try convincing a credit card company to let you accept credit cards on your website without encrypting the traffic.