4 ms·
Background prior to debate[1]: "During an event at the Cambridge Union Society in November 2018, Žižek had called Peterson's work "pseudo-scientific", labeled
by aspenmayer 7y ago
Background prior to debate[1]:
"During an event at the Cambridge Union Society in November 2018, Žižek had called Peterson's work "pseudo-scientific", labeled him as his "enemy" and criticized Peterson's work on the idea of cultural Marxism. Peterson said he could meet "any time, any place" to debate and it was announced on February 28, 2019 that the debate was scheduled for April 19. The two professors before had argued against happiness as something one should pursue. Peterson had said people should seek meaning through personal responsibility and Žižek had said happiness is pointless and delusional."[1]
Debate itself[2][3]:
"...In a similar fashion, Žižek asked Peterson to name him personal names of "postmodern neo-Marxists" in Western academia and from where he got the statistical numbers because according to him the over-the-top political correctness is opposed to Marxism, on which Peterson did not mention any names, yet statistical percentage of those who declare as Marxists in the academia according to Jonathan Haidt's research and explained replacement of the Marxist idea of class struggle with identity politics by which one group is oppressing the other. Some view this exchange as evidence that cultural Marxism had been invented by Peterson and other members of the intellectual dark web without any evidence of its existence. In the end, they both agreed that happiness is rather a byproduct of life itself."
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peterson%E2%80%93%C5%BDi%C5%BEek_debate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peterson%E2%80%93%C5%BDi%C5%BE...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peterson%E2%80%93%C5%BDi%C5%BEek_debate#Context https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peterson%E2%80%93%C5%BDi%C5%BE...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peterson%E2%80%93%C5%BDi%C5%BEek_debate#Debate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peterson%E2%80%93%C5%BDi%C5%BE...
[3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lsWndfzuOc4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lsWndfzuOc4
- kleer001 7y agoOkay. That's kind of interesting. From all I've digested of Žižek it seems he quite often bathes in exaggeration for theatrics. So, I wouldn't take "pseudo-scientific" as a flat and sincere statement. Also given that Peterson actually IS a scientist (with a few well sited papers). I tried to watch the talk, but there was so much audience hooting and hollering it was too difficult. But still, I don't see any evidence of Peterson being a "crypto-fascist" or "intellectual lightweight" as a previous user accused. The search continues.
- aspenmayer 7y agoI'll concede that Žižek has a flair for theatrics, but I agree with Žižek that Peterson's claims are "pseudo-scientific" because they are fundamentally not truth-claims that are falsifiable. It's simply not science to say the things he's saying. He may wish to use science to fortify his philosophical or sociological claims, but you can't do that without making statements that are fundamentally at odds with the scientific method. Edit: live commentary: https://www.currentaffairs.org/2019/04/live-commentary-on-the-zizek-peterson-debate https://www.currentaffairs.org/2019/04/live-commentary-on-th... a decently even-handed critique of both participants: https://medium.com/discourse/the-hidden-argument-in-the-zizek-peterson-debate-from-a-competitive-debator-4eb3238564c2 https://medium.com/discourse/the-hidden-argument-in-the-zize... an unedited transcipt I found: https://truefalsehoods.com/2019/04/23/transcript-of-zizek-vs-peterson/ https://truefalsehoods.com/2019/04/23/transcript-of-zizek-vs...
- kleer001 7y ago(First, thank you for continuing this discussion. I feel I have to say that because often they fall apart.) (edit: oops, this was to comment on the wikipedia article you posted) So, it seems to me this critique of Peterson's Boogymen of cultural Post-structuralist Neo-Marxists (or something like that) comes down to "He didn't use the right words to describe what he's talking about." as opposed to "What he's describing doesn't exist" or what I seem to smell in the most muddy of critiques "He's a dangerous idiot". In addition, looking at this article: https://www.macleans.ca/opinion/the-jordan-peterson-slavoj-zizek-was-good-for-something/ https://www.macleans.ca/opinion/the-jordan-peterson-slavoj-z... The author says: "He then proceeded to stumble his way through Marxist philosophy with such a shallow assessment as to be laughably incorrect." But then doesn't back it up with anything. And shallow doesn't mean incorrect. So it seems to me that his detractors are grasping at straws. Again, a hearty shrug from me. Though, looking at the work from Andray Domise, the author of above, like his articles and his TED talk "TEDx Toronto: Colour Coded: race, gender, and representation in video games" He seems very very occupied with group identity.
- aspenmayer 7y ago