3 ms·
Some companies (like today’s Microsoft, apparently) have PR arms that are actually good at their jobs—writing articles that are, independent of their ability to
by derefr 7y ago
Some companies (like today’s Microsoft, apparently) have PR arms that are actually good at their jobs—writing articles that are, independent of their ability to advertise their company, actually intellectually gratifying in some way.
People who post things to HN, independent of being shills for any given company, like to post intellectually gratifying things. Sometimes those things happen to also be PR pieces. I don’t think the people who post these things really think about them as being PR pieces; or, if they do, they post them despite that, because in the balance, the piece still works out to be worth reading (in their opinion) even after giving it a demerit for being PR.
I’m not denying that there are shills on HN, mind you. I’m sure there are many of them. But I would say that even those shills probably have some sort of “standards”—only posting the PR pieces available to them if they think they’ll do well here (which means, only posting the pieces someone else who wasn’t a shill would have posted anyway.) To do otherwise might get them banned as spammers (which I do believe does happen—mods want to chime in on that?)
And then we still have the filter of some amount of upvoting being required to get things to the front page, plus (I assume) some sort of behind-the-scenes voting-ring detection. So the upvote signal is likely to express genuine community interest, and therefore to signal that the piece does have value independent of its PR-power.
- BiteCode_dev 7y agoGood PR is not doing the post yourself, but creating a post that is passable enough to be posted by a regular user on your behalf. Just because it is well done does not mean it has good value as news. Indeed, even if it's an ok read, it's giving a lot of attention to a company just because it has the money to attract said attention, no matter the quality of their service. Since the reader's time and energy is limited, it's taking the place of another possible read. In the same way, by allowing this to happen, this lets a company create a fantastic image of itself, that is independent from it's real quality, just because it has the budget to do it. Cumulatively, this can, after years, end up rewriting history, and lead even educated people to make altered judgements and decisions in the future. I'm not saying that as an anti-microsoft attack, I dislike the concept of such powerful PR in general, MS is just here a potential example for this. As an HN reader, I wish there would be a policy about this. But I have no idea what it would look like, or how one could enforce it. So maybe I'm just making a lot of noise for nothing.