4 ms·
Inaccurate title. This person is not infected. The post is about anxiety causing them to slip into old bad habits, not about a brain infection. It's really mo
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
Inaccurate title. This person is not infected.
The post is about anxiety causing them to slip into old bad habits, not about a brain infection.
It's really more like "How a global pandemic is affecting my mind and personal habits."
- onion2k 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metaphor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metaphor
- zkid18 7y agoI find article more clickbait rather than metaphoric
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIt's click bait. HN guidelines suggest the title should be changed in such cases. Your handle is plenty old enough to understand that much about HN.
- onion2k 7y agoThe title is a metaphor (or, more strictly, rhetorical hyperbole.) It's not meant to be taken literally.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYes. I know that. There is also absolutely no way to tell that until you click into it. "Rhetorical hyperbole" is a fancy way of saying "click bait." Edit: To be clear, I only read it because I was expecting a medical piece, not the usual whining about First World Problems where so many people don't know how to stop wringing their hands about our 24/7 news cycle (which isn't remotely unique to the current crisis) and then don't actually want reassurances that "It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine." It was a waste of my time. My father fought in WW2. My mother grew up in Germany during WW2 and its aftermath. The world has been on the brink before and come through it. The same world that was all "Meh, not my problem" when I was homeless also doesn't want to hear "The world can, in fact, get through this." So I find it hugely personally grating to read this overwrought nonsense, frankly.
- dgb23 7y ago> The same world that was all "Meh, not my problem" when I was homeless also doesn't want to hear "The world can, in fact, get through this." So I find it hugely personally grating to read this overwrought nonsense, frankly. I know this was somewhat of a rant, but I still found this statement thought provoking and it clicked with me. It can be exhausting to deal with this type of neglect and self limitation at times. Being consistently empathic and positive is challenging to say the least.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIt's not a rant. It's a very restrained statement of fact. Given how monstrously callous the world was to me when it was just my world in the toilet and on the brink and there were adequate resources for me to be helped but I couldn't access them because fuck me, no, I don't have any empathy for some privileged person who has remote work and a lot of protection from the pandemic whining about how they are back to checking the news constantly and, oh, there isn't even any good discussion anymore on effin Twitter. And this makes the front page and then people have the gall to defend the click bait title. Meanwhile, when I posted about actual solutions to help less privileged people try to access remote work during this crisis, it was dismissed as content marketing for the service I work for and sometimes write about. I also spent some time criticizing the emphasis on ventilators and being attacked for talking about my firsthand experience with lung clearance techniques. Yesterday, I posted a piece about how some doctors are concerned with the 80 percent death rate for people on ventilators and trying to do other things, some of which are very similar to things I talked about. That got three upvotes and the only discussion was someone letting me know the link was broken and someone asking me how the pandemic is impacting the homeless population. I'm downright disgusted with quite a lot of things. But I also know from being on HN for more than a decade that people here literally don't care if I'm in danger of dying and they certainly don't care about my feelings about the whiny oversensitive BS that very privileged people have ridiculously big feelings about because they are too fragile to face a real problem, good god.
- dgb23 7y ago
- have_faith 7y agoIt isn't meant to be, but it is written by the author with the understanding that it will be misconstrued until reading the article. As such it is written to bait the reader into clicking. Even if it also works as a metaphor, it seems bad taste.
- mlnhd 7y agoHow can you tell it's a metaphor without clicking through? Since this is a "novel" virus, I thought it would be about some heretofore unheard of symptom.
- BubRoss 7y agoThis is a rationalization of lying for attention.
- dang 7y agoThis is a case where we can disambiguate the title by appending the subtitle which interprets the metaphor.
- notacoward 7y agoThank you. Just as a meme is a non-physical analog of a gene, this "infection" is a non-physical analog of a virus. We talk about ideas going "viral" all the time and very few seem to mind. The metaphor is apt. This anxiety is contagious in the way that matters. Apparently some work it out by going online and dumping all over other people for no reason. I've seen it in other forums too, but nowhere as much as here.
- mercer 7y agoFor some reason it didn't even occur to me that the title might've been taken literally, but in hindsight that seems odd. I suppose if this is odd, the title can be considered clickbait.
- karlicoss 7y agoThe original title is "How Coronavirus Infected My Brain", and Hackernews stripped "how" (apparently [0] it does it automatically). I think with "How" it definitely feels like a metaphor, not like a claim about some symptom (I'm not a native speaker though!) In hindsight, I guess, I should have edited it straightaway, but thought it wasn't a big deal at the time of posting. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19054830 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19054830
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThe "how" doesn't make as much difference as you imagine. That still sounds like "The exact medical pathway by which I acquired an honest to God brain infection." It really doesn't clear it up. (I'm only replying because you say you aren't a native speaker. The word doesn't really add clarity in this case.)
- mercer 7y agoI'd say it makes a very slight difference to me, but you're probably right.
- DoreenMichele 7y ago"Slight difference" isn't very different from "it doesn't make as much difference as you imagine." I'm not claiming it makes absolutely no difference to anyone ever. I've been caught by the fact that HN strips out "how" at the start of a title, stopped and thought about it and, in most cases, concluded it didn't really add anything of value to the title.
- grawprog 7y agoOn this note, i've noticed a surprising lack of any kind of personal stories or experiences being told about personally experiencing the consequences of this pandemic other than economic, being trapped in their home or the frustrations of pandemic life. The few people that have talked about having it, the NBA player comes to mind, have been criticised for talking about their experiences. I've really yet to hear any actual accounts of anyone or their family being impacted directly by being sick. Which seems kind of odd for something that's supposedly ravaging the world horribly. With previous pandemics, the news loved to get the personal accounts of people. Every day there'd be new footage of hospital beds full of patients, stories about family members and their struggles etc. With this, nothing. Just some numbers being told every day, with no real verification as an excuse to enact some of the most fucked measures and legislation across the world.