4 ms·
Evolution doesn't have to switch off things of no use, but no direct burden. There is no inherent upside statistically in the mating game to "not" being able to
by ggm 7y ago
Evolution doesn't have to switch off things of no use, but no direct burden. There is no inherent upside statistically in the mating game to "not" being able to smell soil, so it would be inherently "wasteful" in gene terms to turn this off. We might have carried this up from simpler forms who benefited from it in positive gene-sense. We won't neccessariy loose it, unless there is a statistically measurable upside benefit, or something like energy consequences.
- RhodesianHunter 7y agoThis seems very unlikely given that most of the various structures and pathways involved in smell in humans don't exist in our earliest (in the bacteria sense) ancestors. It seems far more likely to be a positive associating due to a higher likelihood of finding growing food.
- ggm 7y agook. so at some point we acquired it. it must be either very old, or recent. in either case, the fact it confers at best marginal evolutionary benefit, suggests that it is not strongly linked to what we are as humans, and its net cost to us persisting in the genome confers no disadvantage or, is coupled in gene terms to other attributes (sense of smell in general) which are sufficiently beneficial, it will not disappear
- im3w1l 7y agoBecause of mutations, anything that isn't used will tend to stop working. On the other hand the "tech debt" that comes with everything accidentally relying on everything else working a certain way, is a pressure to conserve past behavior.