4 ms·
But what if they can't have what they want? What if they want the mines reopened, and coal and oil workers back to work, the factories churning out American go
by krapp 7y ago
But what if they can't have what they want?
What if they want the mines reopened, and coal and oil workers back to work, the factories churning out American goods made on American soil, and lifetime employment with a pension and health insurance, a turkey in every pot and two cars in every garage like their fathers or grandfathers had, but the world has moved on, and the jobs and stability they want simply cannot, and will never, exist in the modern world?
What if "socialist" initiatives like nationalized healthcare, UBI and free college are better options?
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThen tell them so. Tell them in a way that they understand. Don't tell them in a way that you understand, and then look down on them because they don't get it.
- jacquesm 7y agoThat's not how voting in America works. People will vote for whoever promises them what they want to hear. You can stand there on the other side of the line with your scientifically supported facts and you'll be an also ran. People actually want to be lied to.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI didn't say "give them scientifically supported facts". I meant that you tell them that your approach is going to get them what they actually want, and that you can deliver and the other guys can't. But to do that, you first have to understand both what they want and how they think. Then you can talk to them in terms they understand. [Edit: I'm not knocking facts. By all means, use them. We absolutely need more reality in our political discourse. But you have to present the facts within their frame of reference, not yours. You need to be able to make a blue-collar midwesterner understand why Trump has let them down without expecting them to adopt the mindset of a coastal liberal.]
- jacquesm 7y agoI think the idea that everything can be understood by everybody, even by those that don't want to expend any effort is a problematic one. Plenty of people don't want to understand, they just want a strong man to lead them and Trump gives them the image of that. Fortunately he's not really a strong man because then the USA would be in even more trouble than it is today. God forbid that an Erdogan or Putin type gains direct control over the United States. Facts aren't always clear cut, they aren't always simple and the world is complex. Knowing that your intended target is unable to understand a certain piece of evidence does not mean that there is a credible path to you being able to 'package' it and them understanding it anyway, especially if understanding it would lead to conclusions about their way of life that are incompatible with the way they would like things to pan out. A conman has a much easier job there. That's asymmetrical and I do not see any solution here. That you hope this can be done speaks to your credit, I am not so sure.