6 ms·
What's surprising to me is that it was allowed before. They have had their own videochat solution for years, so I would expect the usual "eat your own dogfood"
by zozbot234 7y ago
What's surprising to me is that it was allowed before. They have had their own videochat solution for years, so I would expect the usual "eat your own dogfood" approach.
- lowdose 7y agoBut then Alphabet risks that Hangout could become as good as Zoom & Slack combined. The golden rule is no Betabets by Alphabet.
- Judgmentality 7y agoIt's frustrating because Google Hangouts used to be great, and then Google purposefully started cannibalizing their own platform. I really want to know what goes on within Product Management at Google, because looking from the outside in I cannot imagine anything other than sheer incompetence.
- jensvdh 7y agoThe only way to get promoted at Google is to launch new things.
- zozbot234 7y agoThe rumors from inside Google is that there's no way to get credit/be rewarded as an employee simply for maintaining an existing solution, or even for fixing obvious breakage. Every incentive is tilted towards starting new projects, often multiple projects in the same domain directly competing with one another. There are some positives to this of course, but clearly it's being overdone.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cosmodisk 7y agoBut still...As a prod manager,you aren't coming up with new projects every week, your entire job is to ensure the roadmap is decent and not taking the product into the graveyard. The company has so many people and yet can't produce a single product with a decent UX.
- KMag 7y agoI worked at Google 2006-2010, and from where I sat, Google's biggest problems were (1) rapid erosion of corporate culture over that time frame and (2) weak project management. A friend was managing a project on a shoestring budget. Upper management (C-suite) had reviewed the idea and green-lit it. He had been told Larry and Sergei in particular had voiced support. He got it done ahead of schedule and under budget by managing a stream of off-cycle interns. The week it was scheduled to go live, someone in middle management killed it. My friend and his team got zero credit for a job very well done, a big setback for him. He and I were working on an internal tool for datacenter management as a 20% project when I left. I asked him about it later, and our 20% project met a similar fate: enthusiastic support from management, including giving us some resources, all the way through completion, followed by cancellation shortly after completion. My friend left less than a year later. Another friend started a modest improvement to chat as a 20% project, which later got expanded to a full-time project for several engineers. I forget the external name, but the internal code name was "Taco Town" after the SnL skit. Walkabout / Wave was a skunkworks project that used its separate repository, which was very rare at Google. People knew something mysterious was going on down in Australia, but we really had no idea what it was, other than the Google Maps guys were running it and it was named "Walkabout". When Walkabout / Wave came out of skunkworks mode shortly before external launch, the Taco Town team realized they needed to launch very soon or their project would never launch because its functionality was subsumed by Walkabout / Wave. Taco Town rushed its launch, was a bit buggy and had some scalability issues that they knew about, but expected to be able to improve shortly after launch. I think Taco Town's botched launch a few weeks before Walkabout/Wave contributed to initial confusion around Wave and some of Taco Town's problems colored perceptions of Wave's launch. Shortly after I left, Google publicly announced they'd be putting "more wood behind fewer arrows", which was a step in the right direction. I get it that management doesn't want to discourage engineers or stifle innovation, and they know they don't have a good handle on what will be successful and what won't, but keeping around zombie projects gives engineers false hope. The "throw mud at the wall and see what sticks" style of project management can be soul-crushing for talented junior people managing small projects, unless they're properly supported and really get proper credit for doing a very good job engineering something that fails for non-engineering reasons.
- 7y ago
- theandrewbailey 7y agoI'd expect that their own videochat solution changes every year or so.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tibbydudeza 7y agoYet another crappy one.
- jedberg 7y agoWhat do you use when Hangouts is down to discuss fixing Hangouts? :)
- basch 7y agoDuo https://duo.google.com/about/ https://duo.google.com/about/
- brian_herman__ 7y agoWhat do you use when duo/hangouts/meet is down?
- vkou 7y agoE-mail.
- r00fus 7y agoIts not like Google doesn't have a half-dozen other chat services...
- Itaxpica 7y agoStandard practice for Google SREs in any serious outage is to communicate via internally-hosted IRC, since it has a minimum amount of dependencies outside of itself
- kazinator 7y agoPerhaps some internal Hangouts deployment that uses the last known stable version.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 7y agoGooglers don't use Zoom for company work. It was banned as in it can no longer be installed on corp laptops.
- mulmen 7y agoRight but it's also astonishing that was allowed before. If it's not needed for work why would it be installed? Why would any non-work software be allowed on corp laptops?
- shaftway 7y agoBecause sometimes there are contractors, or consultants, or vendors, or partners you work with that for one reason or another can't use internal options.
- Jare 7y agoSpotify is not negotiable tbh.
- rafi_kamal 7y agoGoogle allows personal software to be installed in a corp laptop, subject to restrictions and limitations like this. It's not encouraged, though, and if something happens because you installed a third party software then it's your responsibility.
- hellomyguys 7y agoDon't think it's too uncommon to be able to install Spotify on a work computer.
- x0x0 7y agoWe used Zoom during sales into Google. Therefore, our prospect had to install Zoom.
- jedieaston 7y agoBecause then you don't impede people who might need a new widget installed because everyone and their mother in IT needs to try it and test it before you can use it. Especially at Google scale, where the BeyondCorp system described in their papers could automatically see when an endpoint was doing something naughty, block the user from accessing corporate resources, and give the user information on how to fix it, instead of blocking them from installing anything (even if what they want is perfectly harmless).
- brandmeyer 7y agoWorking with vendors who don't use G Suite for whatever reason.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoYou need to be able to test the competition. A former head of IE used Netscape as his principal browser to stay informed of how it worked.
- mulmen 7y agoObsess over your competitors, not your customers!(?)
- floren 7y agoAs someone who uses Google Meets daily, dogfood is the right word.
- ghaff 7y agoReally? I've started using it more and more recently and it seems pretty good. Dependent on good Internet connectivity like anything else but otherwise it seems straightforward and streamlined--which IMO describes Gsuite in general.
- bronson 7y agoSame, for kid's school. It's awful. Feels abandoned.
- lima 7y agoWhat's wrong with it? We're GSuite customers and I spend at least an hour in Meet each day with zero issues :)
- Thristle 7y agoIt's google, so probably they have at least 3 and one of them will be deprecated every year
- adwww 7y agoDuo, Meets and Hangouts... off the top of my head. With various levels of being merged or not.
- faizshah 7y agoAnyone remember Google Allo? I think it had video? If they made it a discord kind of thing it might have worked but instead they chose to compete with their own products.
- Shank 7y agoAllo didn't have video, that was Duo's job. Hangouts Chat is their Slack/Discord competitor, and Hangouts Classic is the version that everyone has in Gmail. Hangouts Meet is their Zoom competitor. Both Hangouts Classic and Meet can video call, I believe. Chat piggybacks off of Meet. Hangouts Chat and Classic are named the same but are two different products.
- amf12 7y agoSome employees had it installed on corp devices, maybe to connect with their friends and families. Google has banned even installing that app on corp devices. Nobody used it for corp work.
- zozbot234 7y agoCorporate devices should be for work. Especially if you're sheltering-in-place anyway and you're not even physically at the office.
- _delirium 7y agoIt's surprisingly common for people not to own a non-work computer other than a phone/tablet, especially now that prevalence of desktop computers is declining. Some people do still have a home desktop, or a separate personal laptop, but a lot of people I know don't. Or they might have one but it's a shared family computer that's mostly used by the kids, while parents use their work laptops.
- wolco 7y agoIf you ever owned a desktop chance are you have one now. A lot of people skipped them and went straight to an iphone.
- kyuudou 7y agoand if it gets compromised, who's liable and how for what
- azurezyq 7y agoNot surprising at all. I'm also among them. Reasons are: 1. performant laptops are expensive. 2. If not for work, most of the time you don't need it.
- thekyle 7y agoDo you use your work machine for side projects? If so who owns the IP?
- chrisseaton 7y ago> What's surprising to me is that it was allowed before. > They have had their own videochat solution for years, so I would expect the usual "eat your own dogfood" approach. If an engineer from Microsoft has to speak to an engineer from Google, and you think they should both be dog-fooding their own video application... how do you see that working? Just both dig their feet in and never talk to each other? Seems silly to me. One or both are going to have to install a video application that isn't their own aren't they?
- catalogia 7y ago> If an engineer from Microsoft has to speak to an engineer from Google, and you think they should both be dog-fooding their own video application... how do you see that working? They could use a telephone. (Yes, they still exist.) Edit for response: Neither Google nor Microsoft forbid their employees from using telephones, and neither would even consider it. The assumption that they'd dogfood their own video chat platforms is obviously not a supposition that they'd ban telephones. Your comment frames the matter as though a third party video chat service is the only pragmatic option. Video chat was a fringe concept not very long ago, considered mostly to be in the realm of science fiction. Even today, inter-company telephone meetings are still common. Tech-fetishists working in this industry often seem to lose sight of the obvious time-tested solutions that still work today. I think a lot of people are earnestly forgetting that telephones still exist.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> They could use a telephone. Well that's example of what I suggested they'd have to do - use someone else's service.
- dodobirdlord 7y agoWho sent the email scheduling the meeting?
- FriendlyNormie 7y agoI was once invited to the Google campus in Mountain View. The employee showing me around laughed in disbelief when I pulled out my Android phone to show her something. She said that she and all of her coworkers use iPhones.
- duxup 7y agoMy understanding is that 'generally' for a lot of things Google lets teams decide what tools best fit their needs.
- rusty__ 7y agoThey've probably run in to a similar issue to Apple whereby they've found their consumer-grade "phone auntie susan once a week" offerings don't stand up to the needs of everyone working remotely needing screen sharing, hot seating in and out all day long chats. We're using MS Teams and it seems to be pretty great for us (team of about 15), we use Skype to contact the remaining 20ish more junior staff who don't need Teams licenses just to be able to keep in touch with their work and keep the face to face communication going.