9 ms·
Can Exercise Keep You Young?
- bootload 16y ago"... Half of the mice were allowed to run on a wheel for 45 minutes three times a week, beginning at 3 months. These rodent runners were required to maintain a fairly brisk pace, Dr. Tarnopolsky said: “It was about like a person running a 50- or 55-minute 10K.” (A 10K race is 6.2 miles.) The mice continued this regimen for five months. ..." Do this every day for five months, year in year out? A 10km/hr pace might not seem fast but I'll bet you most people will not keep this up for long. The will power required, level of exertion and increased injury sees to this.
- mhb 16y agoYour other points are reasonable, but the risk of increased injury is easily addressed by choice of exercise - swimming, rowing, etc.
- bootload 16y ago"... the risk of increased injury is easily addressed by choice of exercise - swimming, rowing, etc. ..." what about your bones? "... The best exercise for your bones is the weight-bearing kind, which forces you to work against gravity. Some examples of weight-bearing exercises include weight training, walking, hiking, jogging, climbing stairs, tennis, and dancing. Examples of exercises that are not weight-bearing include swimming and bicycling. Although these activities help build and maintain strong muscles and have excellent cardiovascular benefits, they are not the best way to exercise your bones. ..." ~ http://www.niams.nih.gov/Health_Info/Bone/Bone_Health/Exercise/default.asp http://www.niams.nih.gov/Health_Info/Bone/Bone_Health/Exerci...
- mhb 16y agoIt wouldn't seem a great leap, then, to combine swimming/rowing/bicycling for its anti-aging benefits with weight lifting for your bones.
- bootload 16y ago"... combine swimming/rowing/bicycling for its anti-aging benefits with weight lifting ..." The study was looking at how endurance exercise reduced mitochondrial damage. Rowing, riding and swimming are endurance sports, so most likely yes. "... The systemic mitochondrial rejuvenation through endurance exercise promises to be an effective therapeutic approach to mitigating mitochondrial dysfunction in aging and related comorbidities. ..." ~ http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2011/02/18/1019581108.abstract http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2011/02/18/1019581108.abst...
- electromagnetic 16y agoIIRC the Roman Army had hit its sweet spot at a 15-mile (~25km) march a day. They'd force march on occasion, but this was rarely before battle. They wanted their soldiers rested before battle. I'd guess that exercising much beyond 2 miles/hour is going to be detrimental to your body if done daily. Our bodies were built for endurance, which is why our locomotion is derived from gravity. Our ancestors hunted animals that survived by their endurance.
- quickpost 16y ago2 miles / hour seems very slow! Typo?
- electromagnetic 16y agoNot really, if you're forcing yourself to go faster you're likely doing damage. You might be able to go faster for shorter periods or slower for a lot longer. However, I would think if the Roman Legion had been doing 25km in 3 hours I doubt they would have won any wars. Their forced marches were to make them march longer, not faster. I'm saying 2 miles/hour because the Romans only managed around 1.5 with weight.
- rprospero 16y agoMy office is three miles from my house. If I walk at a slow, I-don't-want-to-go-to-this-meeting pace, I get to work in forty minutes. Same time for getting home. I did this for five years and I wasn't even in shape. I'm not arguing that the Romans were slackers. Given the effort it takes to setup a Roman castra, the marching might be the least strenuous part of the soldier's day. Also, my daily walk is on paved sidewalk across mostly level ground, while the Romans often didn't have such advantages. For an able bodied person walking through a shopping mall, three miles an hour is perfectly healthy and reasonable.
- zeteo 16y agoBy no means. The average marching rate for foot-borne, pre-industrial armies has been a pretty consistent 10 miles a day. Only a few exceptionally well organized forces, like the Roman legions, could march more than that on a regular basis. http://www.ibiblio.org/pub/academic/history/marshall/military/mil_hist_inst/m/march2.asc http://www.ibiblio.org/pub/academic/history/marshall/militar...
- georgieporgie 16y ago> > three times a week > Do this every day for five months Three times a week. Also, mice can't ride bicycles.
- boredguy8 16y agoStarting the Monday after Superbowl I started walking to and from work (1.5 miles) and going on a 50-60 minute walk/jog every other day. I also revamped my diet. This is going from almost no fitness to moderate levels. I've lost 16 lbs. since then, and I'm up to 7km in that 60 minute evening walk/jog. I really don't see a 9 minute mile (basically a 10k in 55 minutes) as incredibly out of reach. I've gone from a 17 minute mile to a 13:30 mile in less than a month, and that was with a week break from the evening exercise. A 9 minute mile is a decent jog for someone that's at a healthy point. By the way: evening walks are a great time to listen to podcasts or lectures!
- rmason 16y agoFunniest comment in that article that I've read all month: Ok, Ok, you don’t have to beat me over the head with more research. You’ve convinced me. I’m going to force the mice in my apartment to exercise more.
- shasta 16y agoPossibly even the funniest comment in that article of all time.
- electromagnetic 16y agoWhat I don't get is that they're "exercising" rats that are being forcibly sedate. Rats travel long distances on a daily basis, they have large areas in the wild (not so much in the city) where they find food. For a fair study you would have to find how much a wild non-urban rat "exercises" during a day and then up that to see whether exercise will keep them young.
- cj 16y agoBefore human civilization I suspect that we walked much more than a couple miles per day. Caging the rats is comparable to the reduction in daily movement due to cars, availability of food, etc. Setting the baseline to non-urban rats would tell us more about the health of prehistoric humans than modern ones.
- electromagnetic 16y agoFor their study to be valid in proving that exercise prolongs 'youthfulness' it requires that they be meeting the species normal exercise limits before expanding on them, otherwise they're actually performing a study on how sedentary lifestyles reduce youthfulness. This is a scientific study that isn't being accurate about what it's even studying, which makes me instantly dubious of any of its results.
- cj 16y agoThat is assuming the definition for exercise is any level of activity above the standard and expected activity level of a species. Put into context, your reasoning implies that a rat running around all day looking for food is not exercise.
- Aron 16y agoPrecisely. Sadly scientists (like other humans) are all too willing to step aside and let the press do whatever it pleases to maximize their publicity. The 'last psychiatrist' had a recent posting relating this to how certain scientific facts appear to later become unreproducible. The truth being that the original research was merely misrepresented, usually via a motivated lack of skepticism and disregard of nuance.
- sarahmccrum 16y agoMy big question is about the difference between this kind of body pummelling exercise and gentler types of exercise such as the Chinese have done for millennia to promote longevity. I don't think the Chinese live longer than Americans or europeans, but then most of them don't do their traditional exercise styles any more. But i know that the feeling you get after an hour of Chinese-style exercise is so much fresher and more invigorating than after strong western style exercise. In my experience western style exercise circulates your energy (which is really good for you) and also drains it but Chinese exercise actually boosts your energy as well as circulating it. This is only based on personal experience - no science, but it would be worth investigating more seriously for anyone interested in longevity.