3 ms·
> It's official policy that scientists cannot question government decisions. The party in power has "had enough of experts" Can you provide a reference for eit
by nailer 7y ago
> It's official policy that scientists cannot question government decisions. The party in power has "had enough of experts"
Can you provide a reference for either or both of these?
Regarding the first, the scientists lead the government to making decisions. As you read in the article:
> Until March 12, the risk level, set by the government’s top medical advisers on the recommendation of the scientists, remained at “moderate,” suggesting only the possibility of a wider outbreak.
I you're suggesting the government is ignoring the scientists, this is incorrect given the evidence we've seen so far.
I believe "had enough of experts" was a Michael Gove quote related to Brexit, not related to the pandemic, and you've cut it short:
“I think the people in this country have had enough of experts... from organisations with acronyms saying that they know what is best and getting it consistently wrong."
Michael Gove, Sky News, 3 June 2016
https://fullfact.org/blog/2016/sep/has-public-really-had-enough-experts/ https://fullfact.org/blog/2016/sep/has-public-really-had-eno...
- LatteLazy 7y agoYou've provided you're own reference for having "had enough of experts". For being sacked for questioning policy, look into the experience of Dr David Nutt. Sacked for questioning government drug policy. Or the Badger culls. I think you've missed my point a bit with your quote: it's easy to get all the scientists to agree with your policy if you start sacking anyone who doesn't isn't it? And that's what the UK government (this one is particularly bad but other too) always do. Science is a justification for predecided policy. Science doesn't set policy. And per the article, the government didn't even manage that. Boris was clearly warned 100k people would die. He got that in writing. His choice was to do nothing. But it's scientists' fault he ignored that. Even as he watched and laughed at other western nations both having massive issues and issuing their own isolation policies. The truth here is that this is what happens when you behave this way. It's actually very childish to complain you were warned but it doesn't count because you were not warned enough...
- nailer 7y agoWell no, the quote regarding "had enough of experts" wasn't a reference for your argument, it was pointing out that you seem to manipulating a quote by cutting it to mean something different and attributing it to a different topic. David Nutt was indeed fired by the Conservatives for making evidence based recommendations about drug policy. I believe at the time Boris Johnson was the Foreign Secretary. I'm not sure how you attribute firing someone over drug decriminalisation recommendations to the Foreign Secretary. We're done here.
- LatteLazy 7y ago>We're done here. Lol.