2 ms·
Yes, predictions made from March 2 data about the COVID-19 are objectively outdated, because it's a rapidly changing situation. By March 2, 4000 died around th
by kazinator 7y ago
Yes, predictions made from March 2 data about the COVID-19 are objectively outdated, because it's a rapidly changing situation.
By March 2, 4000 died around the world. Today, more than 1200 residents of just Queens, New York have died.
Lots of leaders around the world made the wrong guess with overly optimistic thinking, like what is in that paper.
> Look, you keep moving the goalposts.
Based on the March 2 view of the situation, what it says is not without justification. The paper doesn't claim to be asserting unvarnished truths. It makes some forward looking statements that are in the rational range, based on what was known.
The arguments in that paper do not hold today; it is not appropriate to wield that paper due to its connection to expertise.
It's like referring to last month's weather forecasts in the middle of a hurricane.
- thu2111 7y agoSo, I don't agree at all that the paper is wrong. The results are about the virus itself, which would scale up. You seem to be arguing their data was totally wrong but haven't explained why, other than it's a month old, although the virus had been around for three months by then. But the core argument here isn't actually about the virus. It's epistemological. You have been arguing for censorship on an exceptionally weak basis and haven't acknowledged that. Every criteria you've put forward for deciding what experts should be allowed to speak is invalid or unusable. That's more relevant than this specific paper, which was simply an example to disprove your position.
- kazinator 7y agoI don't agree with censorship (of which a private sector site deleting some article or post is not an example, by the way). The example paper should continue to be available. In fact, it is important that it be available; it has historical interest going forward. > Every criteria you've put forward for deciding what experts should be allowed to speak is invalid or unusable. That's hardly the case.