3 ms·
"No True Scotsman" is about moving the goalposts regarding to the quality or suitability of something. We wouldn't reasonably say that a Dane isn't a True Scots
by kazinator 7y ago
"No True Scotsman" is about moving the goalposts regarding to the quality or suitability of something. We wouldn't reasonably say that a Dane isn't a True Scotsman, right?
A piece of crap unsuitable for production use could be a Lisp. Lisp 1.5 is Lisp; I wouldn't use it today. Lisp or not is not about quality, but semantics. Clojure lacks or changes numerous semantics which define Lisp. That's not statement about quality, just otherness.
Clojure doesn't call itself a Lisp; though the main website claims it is a Lisp dialect. Dialects are defined by mutual intelligibility. An Osaka man speaks a dialect which is understood in Tokyo. The mutual intelligibility between Lisp dialects and Clojure does not extend very far beyond (+ 2 2).