4 ms·
>According to Eileen Huang ’22, requiring undergraduates — many burdened by sickness, hectic home lives or living thousands of miles away from the University —
by duxup 7y ago
>According to Eileen Huang ’22, requiring undergraduates — many burdened by sickness, hectic home lives or living thousands of miles away from the University — to devote the same level of attention and focus to their classes as they would in the Elm City seems unfair.
I think there is merit to this concern.
I don't know if passing automaticly is the right choice but experiences durring these events can be quite wide ranging.
Just for me I find that some my neighbors complain they are bored. Me, my kids are at home, I have to manage their schooling, I have to work, my wife needs to work...and the youngest needs constant attention. I've never had less time / sleep.
Now students might not have kids but they too might have a great variety of challenges other students / professors don't have.
- dillonmckay 7y agoSome do. Some would otherwise be homeless. All walks of life attend college.
- 333c 7y agoTo me that's the most compelling argument: equity. Some students come from a background with very few resources and an unstable home environment, or no home to speak of. These students shouldn't be at an academic disadvantage because of a global pandemic.
- dillonmckay 7y agoI mean, I agree, they shouldn’t, but the reality is, they are. Now, what happens if this extends for multiple semesters? Are all the Ivy schools going to PASS/FAIL online until graduation?
- 333c 7y agoI'm not trying to get into a lengthy discussion so I'll leave it after this comment. > the reality is, they are. But Yale admins/faculty have the power to change that. Whether the change is worth it (and what the best course of action is) is a matter for debate. But I wouldn't say that the best course of action is to sit back and say "that's just the reality of the situation" when we have a capability to effect change. > Now, what happens if this extends for multiple semesters? > Are all the Ivy schools going to PASS/FAIL online until graduation? That's certainly not an ideal course of action, but (in my view) it may be what the Ivies are forced to do.
- username90 7y agoEquity argument doesn't seem to hold. Why not just give course credits to everyone in USA and not just those who were rich/lucky enough to go to Yale? Would be way more fair, no?
- dehrmann 7y agoAn optional mulligan for classes seems most fair. You still have to earn it, but make it so it doesn't impact GPAs.
- LanceH 7y agoI would wager that for the vast majority of students attending Yale that the reduction in social time is way more than the increase in family duties. At least they should have reduced social interactions at this point. Sure there are some impacted, treat them individually (that's one of the things you pay Ivy league rates for, right?). Wheeling out a sob story of a handful of students in order to grant benefits to everyone just doesn't make sense. The school should be rigorous and push students as best it can. That's how I viewed school, though, and I realize it is a minority opinion.