3 ms·
To me the real question is whether any particular virus lineage evolved independently, or started out as an organelle or other apparatus of a cell, and got loos
by ncmncm 7y ago
To me the real question is whether any particular virus lineage evolved independently, or started out as an organelle or other apparatus of a cell, and got loose.
I doubt we will ever know, about most viruses, because they evolve so fast. But it would be seriously cool to find a bacterium using them for communication or as an extra-cellular library.
We already know about plasmids, of course, and there are plasmid viruses that dispense with the protein wrapping. But do any bacteria communicate, or store information in the environment, via non-viral genes wrapped in a viral protein coat? Would we notice if they did?
We still would not know whether the bacteria co-opted a virus, or developed the mechanism by itself. Indeed, it could be that the original developer of, say, those mosquito-shaped phages was wiped out when they went rogue.
- qqqqquinnnnn 7y agothis is a fascinating line of inquiry, and comes down to the methods of detection being insufficiently fine-grain. it's challenging to tell apart all of the pieces in a metagenomic sample except through assembly. A "viral plasmid" like you describe would go unnoticed simply because it would map to another sequence assembly. there's indication of high copy-number plasmids in bacteria sometimes. not sure if anyone has looked to see if any of those are kept in the outside of the cell. usually imaged cells are washed very well before imaging, otherwise background is off the charts...