5 ms·
I took a data visualisation class in uni that handled this really cleverly. The second assignment sounded very easy. The teacher provided links to the sources w
by kqr 7y ago
I took a data visualisation class in uni that handled this really cleverly. The second assignment sounded very easy. The teacher provided links to the sources where we could find data.
Most people figured that with such a simple assignment (not significantly harder than the first one, which was also easy-ish) they could put off doing it until the last moment.
Most people failed.
This real world data needed hours upon hours of cleaning before it was in any way useable. Of course, the teacher knew this, gave bonus points to the ones who did start in time, and then extended the deadline as he had expected to from the start.
Never again will I underestimate the dirtiness of real world data. One of the best teachers I had.
- jtanderson 7y agoI’m currently preparing a data visualization course to be taught this fall, and I would love to hear more about this! If you’d be willing to share some of those resources or the contact information for your professor, I’d really appreciate it. You can find contact info at the link in my profile :)
- 0az 7y agoNot parent poster, but Thomas Powell is the Data Viz instructor at UCSD.
- adenadel 7y agoDo you still have the assignment?
- starpilot 7y agoThis is universal to STEM degrees I think. In mechanical engineering classes you analyze a beam, in real life you analyze an assembly with 50 components that have undergone 100 revisions with 20 different materials and loading from 4 directions that vary with time. Oh, and you have 4 sensors to give you information to analyze critical stresses. But one of them is broken, and Bob who can fix it is on PTO until next Monday, so... Internships are supposed to fill this gap but it'd be nice if all students could get a taste of real world systems and data. For tech, maybe if they could partner with the IT department at the school to get them exposed to real, messy data. Maybe there are some teaching datasets with over a billion rows that people could play around with.
- mcrad 7y ago> This is universal to STEM degrees I think. In mechanical engineering classes you analyze a beam, in real life you ... Hard to believe this. Don't these degrees require rigorous laboratory assignments where the student learns to differentiate best case scenario with real world uncertainties? STEM is not just some IT certification
- Underqualified 7y agoAs a mechanical engineer : No, my education didn't. The problem is that most real world problems take too much time to really solve to fit in any modern ciriculum.
- mcrad 7y agoHmmm. We had a whole course on measurement systems that get to the heart of understanding that source of your data and inevitable bias/error is more important than just crunching the data as given. For example, from a typical four year degree.
- starpilot 7y agoNot really. MechE courses are really theoretical, and the labs are focused on just being enough to demo the theories. Most of my professors had never worked in industry, they had been in academia their entire lives. Even they wouldn't know how to bridge the gap. In an ideal world, we'd have separate tracks for people entering industry versus academia/research, but that's a long way off.
- mcrad 7y agoThat's insane. ME degrees that I know seem to be defined by industry (ie. application of theory). Nobody pursues that degree to stay in academia/research. Anyway you can always pursue an advanced degree if you want to stay in academia. Don't get it twisted though - STEM is not a vocation as per your suggestion that "people entering industry" deserve a special path.
- 7y ago
- ehnto 7y agoEdit: the comment I replied to has since been edited to show how the teacher understood what he was doing, and how he made it teachable lesson and not a punitive one. Not to miss the point, but I don't think "All my students failed" is the mark of a good teacher. It sounds like the teacher failed to prepare their students for the nature of the assignment. Perhaps he was surprised as they were when they all failed, as I doubt failing most of his class was his intention.
- gcatalfamo 7y agoYou are being downvoted but you are exactly on point. If some fail they may be bad students, but if the majority of my students fail they're not bad students, it is me who is a bad teacher.
- xaedes 7y agoFailing is a form of learning. Enabling to fail (preferably in a safe way) is very valuable for learning.
- ehnto 7y agoAgreed, and the now edited comment illustrates how the teacher made it a safe lesson. That portion wasn't in the comment when I replied, and it sounded more like the teacher simply failed to prepare their students.
- thablackbull 7y ago> Of course, the teacher knew this, gave bonus points to the ones who did start in time, and then extended the deadline as he had expected to from the start. I think what he meant is they 'failed' to get it completed on time and it was meant as a teaching lesson.
- ehnto 7y agoThat wasn't in the original comment.