2 ms·
Thanks for the links. It clears many things, but the main problem stills remain. Let me put you this example problem. "We have a box full of marbles and we can
by pvaldes 7y ago
Thanks for the links. It clears many things, but the main problem stills remain.
Let me put you this example problem. "We have a box full of marbles and we can take two marbles out of the box each day. How many time it would take us to empty the box of marbles?
As you had noticed yet, this is an unsolvable problem
Now lets assume than we examine a Greenland shark's eye lense and register a value of "X" remaining radioactive carbon-14 atoms and then we take a look to a human eye lense of known age and found "Y" remaining radioactive C14 atoms.
To simplify the problem we will assume that all atoms in a eye lense are trapped there forever, no new carbon atoms were physically added or removed, and the size, weight, and fiber density in the lense are the same for both human and shark.
Having in mind that decay ratio is independent on taxonomy and there is not any reason to think that radioactivity would decay faster in a particular vertebrate... if X = Y; could we conclude than the shark and the human had the same age?
The answer is: Not, we can't infer the shark age. And this is the same problem than with the box of marbles.
- kgwgk 7y agoI don’t understand what you’re talking about. Do you mean that radiocarbon dating of organic material in general is impossible? Do you mean that radiocarbon dating of the embryonic nucleus of the eye lens of a vertebrate in particular is impossible?
- pvaldes 7y agoBoth are possible if, and only if, some conditions are fullfilled first. I don't see nothing in the article suggesting that, and I spot at least one serious flaw in the design. But I don't know everything, and I could be wrong, obviously.
- kgwgk 7y agoThere are several papers and theses (including this one about the Greenland shark http://www2.bio.ku.dk/bibliotek/phd/Julius%20Nielsen.pdf http://www2.bio.ku.dk/bibliotek/phd/Julius%20Nielsen.pdf) looking at the isotopic profile of the different layers of fish eye lenses, down to the embryonic nucleus. Maybe all those researchers are onto something. Or maybe they are all wrong. I have no dog on this fight anyway.