6 ms·
How Does Kidz Bop Censor Songs?
- alanfalcon 7y agoVery cool site/presentation of a mildly amusing and thought provoking topic. The quiz was just the right length to leave me wanting more rather than bouncing. And it all works great on mobile.
- fennecfoxen 7y agountil you want to go back from one list of censored words to the page you were on right before, and then you're back here at HN
- etrabroline 7y agoWhen browsers give up control to web pages, we can't be surprised when a website's poor design decisions affect the browsing experience itself. (and not just the look of a page)
- meristem 7y agoThat just happened to me and means I will not see the content. Awesome design choice.
- watersb 7y agoRegarding the actual music, I actually love it. I was exposed to KidZ Bop as a parent with little kids ten years ago, and now I can torture them as teenagers BWAHAHAHA As a technical style, consider how this is produced: Record every take many many different performances, then splice together the best in very short bits, usually one phrase at a time. Wouldn't be viable before , but perhaps easy enough now. We take digital non-linear editing for granted now, but kids I dare you to try this on a Tascam 4-Track...
- dehrmann 7y ago> splice together the best in very short bits, usually one phrase at a time Max Martin does this for a single singer all the time.
- fiblye 7y agoI didn't look too much into this, but is it possible that the increase of censorship isn't just that Kidz Bop is stricter now, but that pop music today has more profanity? >Kidz Bop is teaching gender role conformity and race identification and pushing kids to grow up quicker, a sociological phenomena known as “kids getting older younger” (KGOY). This is another weird thing. It's assumed that we're all legally kids until 18 now, and that's being extended with more people attending college and it often being seen as a time to have fun, relax, and enjoy yourself without serious responsibility. Many of our ancestors were working jobs at 13 and some were having kids of their own. Not to say that's the way it should be, but recent trends make it feel like childhood has extended. I personally didn't really feel like an adult until solidly into my mid-20s. Edit: It seems like "kids" here might be referring to smaller children acting like teenagers. Even in that case, I think little kids playing with toys and games all day is fairly new. Most were doing chores or actual work throughout history.
- fennecfoxen 7y ago> KGOY Really? I looked at the "Identity" section and sure, they just wrote out "lesbian transgender life" from Born This Way, but they also turned "find a man" into "find the one" and do similar things for "woman"... You can say many things about these replacements, but the one I'm not sure about is that the replacement is in the service of making kids get older, younger. It seems to me just like they just want to make all that into something anodyne, which if anything is the anti-KGOY... unless the alternative is neither Kidz Bop nor the original music, but instead, something more like Raffi? I'm not sure how realistic that is, though.
- burkaman 7y agoReading the study they cite (https://urj.uccs.edu/index.php/urj/article/view/266 https://urj.uccs.edu/index.php/urj/article/view/266), it's not that the replacements have an agenda, it's that replacing a few lyrics doesn't really cover up the original intent of a song, and a lot of the songs they cover have non-kid-friendly themes. Another major complaint is the music videos tend to feature kids having fun by dancing around a big house with fancy clothes and expensive stuff, which romanticizes wealth and promotes consumerism. Lyrics romanticizing wealth like "can't you taste this gold" tend not to be censored. The basic idea is that playing the Kidz Bop version of a Flo Rida song for your kid is similar to showing them the airplane-censored version of Pulp Fiction. If they're too young for the real thing, they're probably too young for the censored version.
- saagarjha 7y agoInteresting, but quite unusable on iPhone SE :( It’d be nice if they nice if they explained why certain things were censored as well; I couldn’t figure out some of them. I wonder how Kidz Bop comes up with their replacements…
- pimlottc 7y agoThis looks cool, but unfortunately the text doesn’t all fit on one screen on my iPhone SE and there is no way to scroll.
- freehunter 7y agoSame on an iPhone 11. Bottom is cut off and no way to scroll down.
- dehrmann 7y agoI can't imagine what they'd do with "Semi-Charmed Life." One of the radio edits cuts half the bridge. I could also see some artists just saying "No, this song is about drugs and sex; you can't cover it."
- judge2020 7y agoThere's almost zero-reason for a record label or artist to turn down a kids bop cover if Kids Bop thinks they can rewrite it to work for their exclusive audience.
- dehrmann 7y agoArtistic integrity.
- jariel 7y agoI can barely believe I'm reading this. I mean, of course many artists would allow it, but it should be obvious that many wouldn't consider it for a second. You do realize there was a time when artists wouldn't allow their music to be used in commercials, and this kind of thing, right? Completely distorting a bit of art for the 'target demographic' is usually way out of most artists' area of interest.
- JackFr 7y agoThey can’t actually stop you from covering it (at least in the US for non-dramatic music) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_license https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_license Of course you have to pay royalties.
- catchmeifyoucan 7y agoThis is a cool way to get people to label data and validate data models with a varied set of people
- reaperducer 7y agoWith advances in deepfake technology, it would seem possible that in the near future, this sort of thing could be automated. If I ruled the world, I'd run all popular music through a deeepfake AI that corrects the grammar.