4 ms·
Conflict-of-interest is a human-invented notion that is rooted in the idea that the world is black and white, and it must be one or the other. That isn't the na
by dheera 7y ago
Conflict-of-interest is a human-invented notion that is rooted in the idea that the world is black and white, and it must be one or the other. That isn't the nature of how the rest of the universe operates.
All that is needed is a weighting factor between the two loss functions (in this case, obligations) to deal with cases like this, and to make the policy (in this case, term sheet) continuous and differentiable as well.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> All that is needed is a weighting factor between the two loss functions Assuming this is sarcasm. If not, it’s an employment guarantee for litigators.
- dheera 7y agoThe ligitators can check to see if the loss function was evaluated correctly to within some sigma, and the ligitators can be robotic as well, in a couple decades from now. Most of what lawyers do is apply patterns they know from before for $900/hr, and that's exactly what machine learning is good at. SoftBank is all about AI and I actually don't think AI lawyers would be a bad thing; it would be nice if they futurized their own corporate and investment structure by design instead of following today's defaults, including "fiduciary duty" in an absolute sense, which I think is an antiquated concept for a society 100 years from now. SoftBank has the power to redesign concepts such as boards, shares, equity from the ground up, and they should be doing experiments with those ideas.
- saghm 7y ago> Conflict-of-interest is a human-invented notion That doesn't seem like a particular relevant critique here; it's not like naturally occurring corporate boards or some universal law of fiduciary duty are things we've observed outside of humanity. Why shouldn't human-invented heuristics apply to situations that as far as we know only occur in human interactions?
- RHSeeger 7y agoI'll admit, that does sound like the description of an onion'ey / college humor-ey thing I'd like to see. I makes me think of the Clubbing in the Wild video [1]. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8zwIphm5r4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8zwIphm5r4
- alasdair_ 7y ago>Conflict-of-interest is a human-invented notion Literally every legal concept is a human-invented notion.
- dheera 7y agoSure, but to me, ALL human-invented notions are subject to interpretation and change over the times. We had kingdoms, slaves, and eye-for-eye punishment before and we largely don't have those concepts today in the developed world. The same is true for conflict-of-interest, fiduciary duty, and today's version of capitalism. If I had said "we don't need slaves" 400 years ago, I would have been downvoted like crazy. And here I am, saying conflict-of-interest and fiduciary duty will be antiquated ideas, and I'm being downvoted here today. Let's have an open mind about the future, shall we? I'd rather in a community like this we put everything we blindly assume today on the table with an open mind and discuss how we can change or improve the system. On a related note, AlphaGo is able to play against itself using a single CPU/GPU, and it gets better by doing so. Why can't a human play against itself and get better as well? Are we brainwashing ourselves into thinking we are unable to do that, and so we are not trying?
- gamblor956 7y agoIf I had said "we don't need slaves" 400 years ago, I would have been downvoted like crazy. European countries began banning the slave trade in the 1400s... And here I am, saying conflict-of-interest and fiduciary duty will be antiquated ideas, and I'm being downvoted here today The first will never be an antiquated idea as long as conflicting interests exist. Conflicting interests don't need to be hostile to each other, they just need to be conflicting in the sense that their interests do not align. As I stated earlier, conflict-of-interest rules merely act to either prevent the conflict or require both sides to knowingly waive the conflict in their shared agent. Fiduciary duty governs the heart of professional workers. It binds lawyers, accountants, etc., to the interests of their clients. This concept will continue to exist as long as their are professions and as long as professionals can have multiple clients.
- wolco 7y agoIf you play games against yourself you will get better. No mystery playing vs others exposes new game plays. Morals change with time.
- gamblor956 7y agoConflict-of-interest is not rooted in the idea that the world is black-and-white. It's the opposite. It's rooted in the idea that the world is shades of gray, and so the conflict-of-interest rules try to (a) eliminate situations where you would have to choose between conflicting sides, or (b) get permission from both sides to remain after advising them of the conflict. Trying to turn this into some silly algorithmic calculation is a fundamental misunderstanding of what conflict of interest is or even that most conflicts are not objectively valuable terms that can be resolved numerically.