2 ms·
This Andy Schlafly appears to be a bit of a quack from the dialog, but I am not convinced Prof. Lenski was right to deny him the data. I'm admittedly quite una
by paulgb 18y ago
This Andy Schlafly appears to be a bit of a quack from the dialog, but I am not convinced Prof. Lenski was right to deny him the data.
I'm admittedly quite unaware of how science works, but would this be a correct analogy: Initech uses GPL code in a product, hacker writes Initech asking for source, Initech says "no, you do not have such and such qualifications, you wouldn't know what to do with the source, so you can't have it".
I looked up section viii. of the PNAS guidelines and at first glance it doesn't seem he quoted it out of context. In fact it specifically says "readers", not "qualified scientists" as in another guideline.
Obviously Andy Schlafly's intentions were to discredit Prof. Lanski, and he was not qualified to examine the data. Prof. Lenski made the judgement call to deny him the data. But, having submitted to PNAS, is it his call to make?