Once the project got rolling, getting Roy to actually produce code was like pulling teeth. I talked to the other leads and found out that Roy talked a good game

Once the project got rolling, getting Roy to actually produce code was like pulling teeth. I talked to the other leads and found out that Roy talked a good game in front of clients but required a baby-sitter to actually get anything done. He was always on the critical components not because he was a great developer, but because the lead or architect was already paying extra attention to the critical components and could more easily manage the babysitting. And none of this came through in the peer reviews, beyond the 2 in Works Independently? I think the review system here broke down in the peer area - no one who was working with him was communicating the vital info on this one, beyond just numeric scores.