4 ms·
IANAL either but I do know a little about contract law because I was involved in a legal dispute involving contract law [1]. One of the fundamental principles
by lisper 7y ago
IANAL either but I do know a little about contract law because I was involved in a legal dispute involving contract law [1]. One of the fundamental principles of contract law is that for a contract to be legally binding there has to have been a "meeting of the minds" [2], i.e. the two parties have to actually have agreed to the terms of the contract. Merely publishing terms of service does not constitute a legally binding contract. Think about it: I could put ToS on my site that say, "By using this site you agree to pay me $1M." If I were to try to enforce that I guarantee you I would not prevail.
Binding arbitration clauses in ToS are there primarily to make people think that they can't sue.
[1] https://blog.rongarret.info/2011/12/cosmo-and-me-part-3-how-wall-street.html https://blog.rongarret.info/2011/12/cosmo-and-me-part-3-how-...
[2] https://contract-law.laws.com/contract-law/meeting-of-the-minds https://contract-law.laws.com/contract-law/meeting-of-the-mi...
- nabla9 7y agoThe US has binding consumer arbitration. In the US those are not empty clauses, despite the fact that they break many legal principles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AT%26T_Mobility_LLC_v._Concepcion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AT%26T_Mobility_LLC_v._Concepc...
- jellicle 7y agoNabla is correct and the prior two commenters are wrong. Although many people think that arbitration clauses are unenforceable, in fact they are completely and totally enforceable under US law in every state. When you take your [service] to court, it will get kicked out immediately and your dispute will be adjudicated by an arbitrator usually chosen by and paid by the [service], and that will be the extent of the justice available to you. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Arbitration_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Arbitration_Act
- lisper 7y agoI didn't say that arbitration clauses are unenforceable. They are enforceable. In fact, one of the references I cited explicitly spelled that out in painful personal detail. What I said was that merely publishing ToS on your web site does not constitute a binding contract. If you don't have a binding contract, then nothing in the ToS is enforceable.
- omginternets 7y agoHang on, I think y'all are talking past each other. The claim (as I've understood it) is: 1. Binding Arbitration is enforceable. 2. Binding Arbitration clauses fall under contract law. 3. By virtue of point 2, Binding Arbitration clauses require a Meeting of the Minds in order to be valid and enforceable. I think you're attacking a straw man.
- jellicle 7y agoWe started off the thread with "these TOS are dubious, they can be ruled unconscionable..." They aren't dubious, they aren't ruled unconscionable. If you sign up for some service and agree to the terms of service that include arbitration, you're going to arbitration and nothing else. Yes, your click on "I agree to the TOS" is binding on you, no, no one cares that you were closing your eyes or crossing your fingers or whatever. Your use of the service shows your agreement.
- lisper 7y ago> Your use of the service shows your agreement. No, that is not necessarily true. If I put in my ToS that by using my site you agree to (say) my installing malware on your machine that will allow me to go into your bank account and take as much money as I want, that will (almost certainly) not be enforceable.
- omginternets 7y agoYou're correct IFF the TOS constitute a valid contract. Contracts can be invalid for a number of reasons, including "one party wasn't made aware they were entering a contract". >Yes, your click on "I agree to the TOS" is binding on you There is no such button in this particular case. >no, no one cares that you were closing your eyes or crossing your fingers or whatever. This is a straw man. Nobody is claiming this. >Your use of the service shows your agreement. That very much depends.