3 ms·
$AU 18b of revenue. The goal was significantly smaller when things started. What this has done to tertiary education in Australia is a very mixed bag. I love th
by ggm 7y ago
$AU 18b of revenue. The goal was significantly smaller when things started. What this has done to tertiary education in Australia is a very mixed bag. I love that we teach people. I hate what it has done to the system overall. Also, NZ and other regional players are exasperated with how Australia marketed. We didn't make things easy for any other players and now its all crashing down, there are mutters of "good"
- JDulin 7y ago> I love that we teach people. > I hate what it has done to the system overall. There are plenty of fine universities the scions of CCP members can attend in China that don't result in the long-term institutional destruction of your nation's educational system. "I love that we teach people" has all the meaninglessness of most feelings of charity, except the price you pay is losing a healthy, stable, focused university system for actual Australians.
- ggm 7y agoOh don't be tiresome. They're from India, Korea, Malaysia, Thailand, all over. We used to have a strategic engagement called the Columbo plan where we taught them on the condition they returned home to do service for their state. I liked that model. Not everything is about china and the CCP. The problem is the venality of the university system now. It's a business.
- JDulin 7y agoOk. Replace the CCP and China in my comment with the other countries you mentioned. You get the exact same mechanism of degradation of your universities, you're just still trying to feel better about it by pointing out that your charity is towards other, poorer, less authoritarian countries than China. The thing policymakers do not understand about globalism is that it takes advantage of existing institutions, necrotizing them in the process, by infecting them with incentives they were never designed to handle. Where once you had a closed system that was working well, you now have a system exposed to graft, grift, and entropy from agents without accountability for how they take advantage of it. So, these agents can find ways to leverage an institutions' own interests against the interests of the people it was originally designed to serve. Much the same way European imperialists could exploit the internal fissures of colonized peoples. Sand in the gears of a clock. This is what happened to manufacturing in the United States. Once the American governance class became culturally and financially loyal to Wall Street, there was nothing stopping developing nations & capital from convincing them to move the entire American industrial base abroad in pursuit of higher returns, no matter the irreversible social damage it caused at home. The Charity Consolation Prize is exactly what those businessmen and policymakers pat themselves on the back with too when they look at the destruction wrought on the American middle class ("Look at home many Indian people we've lifted out of poverty!"). Which would be great! If they were the leaders of India! So you are right that it's driven by greed now, but it's not just "something that happens." The university system in the U.S. and Australia did not just wake up one day and decide to become addicted to Chinese money. Someone gave them a needle full of the stuff to try. It's an exploit in the system that can be closed. It's a choice.
- roenxi 7y agoIf Australia has to choose between destroying our education system and having good relations with scions of the CCP our educational system is toast. We are fortunate that any tension there is self inflicted. Australia can't afford to have bad relations with China; they are too relevant and powerful in the Asia-Pacific region. If we are taking in and educating powerful Chinese students it has nothing to do with charity at any level.
- vinay427 7y agoI know the two countries are relatively closely related (with something approaching freedom of movement, etc.), but why is the Australian tertiary education marketing specifically a concern or source of exasperation for NZ?
- 2019-nCoV 7y agoBecause they're substitute goods.