3 ms·
I live in NYC, and this is possibly the dumbest article I've read in a long, long time. Old people who live in NYC do so because they love it. They're not leav
by crazygringo 7y ago
I live in NYC, and this is possibly the dumbest article I've read in a long, long time.
Old people who live in NYC do so because they love it. They're not leaving.
Headquarters aren't going away. If you're in NYC it's for a good reason (access to labor/industry).
A "much poorer New York"? Not more so than anywhere else.
Develop the strictest test-and-trace? That would require them to get their act together, so no. This isn't a well-managed Asian city.
Subway ridership lower? People take the subway because they don't have a choice. Somebody explain to me how people are going to get to work instead.
And on and on.
The author teaches at a university in Virginia. Reading this article it's hard to imagine he's spent any time here in the city at all.
- downerending 7y ago> Old people who live in NYC do so because they love it. They're not leaving. They might not leave more than before, but they do leave. NYC is a very expensive place to live if you're not rich or don't have a high-paying job.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mtalantikite 7y agoAgreed. If anything the people I’ve noticed fleeing the city are young and relatively new transplants, or the wealthy with summer homes. I’d wager that the fair weather New Yorkers will be the ones that might end up leaving permanently. Maybe some of those are older people, but probably not disproportionately. I’d rather the author spend time thinking about what the city could look like as we come out of this to yield a better future for the city. For instance, let’s finally hand over some streets fully to cyclists, so more people can feel comfortable using bikes as a serious mode of transport. Let’s stop subsidizing luxury apartments and malls throughout the city (looking primarily at you Hudson Yards). Can we make it so the trains don’t break when we do need them, so we don’t have to pack shoulder to shoulder on the subways all the time? Life is definitely going to be different in the city, but I’m not mad if my neighborhood stops being a shopping mall for European tourists and can become a regular community of New Yorkers again.
- unethical_ban 7y agoI triggered on the same notion - that there will be some "Miami 2017" emptying of the largest city in the country. I was rolling my eyes within three paragraphs, and I have only been to NYC once in my life. People still go to festivals and stores despite gun violence. People still drive cars despite accidents. People still go into tall buildings despite terrorist attacks. This too shall pass. Society will adjust to be better prepared for the next time it happens, in many ways. But this article gets far too sweeping about the wrong ideas.