3 ms·
In my experience, bony fishes are not easy to date by counting rings. I tried it and discarded the whole work. If you find 20 rings, you can assume that the fis
by pvaldes 7y ago
In my experience, bony fishes are not easy to date by counting rings. I tried it and discarded the whole work. If you find 20 rings, you can assume that the fish would have 10 years (one opaque ring in summer and other hyaline ring for winter), but unfortunately there are also bifurcated rings, disease's rings, fused and duplicated rings so your animal could have several false duplicated rings, and have only 7 years. In 200 thin rings your error can be awful.
To know the sex of the animals is also important, because females will produce extra hyaline spawn rings starting somewhere in their adult phase. And males... well, nobody nows. They obviously do not get pregnant but do the male whale sharks fight and stop eating?. Not to mention than some fishes can change its sex perfectly.
This with bony fishes, that have true bones. Big sharks are cartilaginous fishes. Cartilaginous tissue dyes badly and rings in its vertebra are less clearly marked. This animals migrate (vertically and horizontally). This means that would probably starve for long periods and then feast and that their vertebras would be subject to a wide range of pressure that could erase rings.
> So any animal that was alive then incorporated that spike in Carbon-14 into their hard parts
The key of the phrase is hard parts. They are looking at cartilage, that is not hard and is a very slow growing and inert structure (what if most of all carbone went to the muscle instead?). The only hard part in whale sharks is the tooth (1-5 milimeters long if I remember correctly). Those teeth are lost and replaced continuously so can't be used to age the animal. Even more, they are releasing carbon-14 at a unknown rate. I would like to see how they address this fact as source of error in their models.
I remain still sceptical when I read this kind of results. Tagging or photoidentification could help, but our best chance is with captive animals.
- x3n0ph3n3 7y ago> I tried it and discarded the whole work. Why wouldn't you publish on how it can't be done reliably?
- pvaldes 7y agoIt just didn't pass the cut. I had plenty of other interesting questions to chew, and moved on. There is not reason anymore to revisit it. Most of those bones would be unreadable today in any case.
- dang 7y agoWhat a great post. That one's going in the next highlights list, if we ever revive those. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=%22hacker%20news%20highlights%22&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...