5 ms·
I have another "Google is shit now" anecdote: a few months ago I wanted to look up some trivia for the movie "Lord of War". I entered this term in Google, and s
by netsharc 7y ago
I have another "Google is shit now" anecdote: a few months ago I wanted to look up some trivia for the movie "Lord of War". I entered this term in Google, and since there was a game that was just released, it responded with "Showing you results for 'God of War'". No results on the front page had anything related to the Nic Cage movie.
- mda 7y agoCan you find the exact search term from your search history?
- netsharc 7y agoIt was "lord of war director's commentary". I thought it was because many more people were googling for the game, but I just tried and Google is still doing this!
- fingerlocks 7y agoIf you click the “search instead for...” then the non-video result was exactly what I believe you wanted.
- mattmanser 7y agoThe point is, why is it doing this? It's not even suggesting both God of War and Lord of War, for me all the results on the first page are about God of War.
- hvis 7y agoIt's probably correcting people's typos, as well as saving a crap-ton of money this way (search results are undoubtedly cached).
- eitland 7y agoAt the cost of destroying their once in-its-own-league quality. Today I use DDG mostly, thanks to Googles choices. DDG is equally bad WRT this but - it is easier to move from DDG to Google (just add !g) than the other way around - and DDG isn't as invasive
- krapp 7y agoI just searched "Lord of War" and the front page is entirely about the movie. Don't know what to tell you.
- netsharc 7y agoSo you replied to my response about the exact search term I used by telling me... this?
- krapp 7y agoYes, you said it was happening currently, so I tried it. The problem you're complaining about doesn't actually appear to exist, at least not objectively.
- eitland 7y agoYou are using a different query it seems. Also as a non native speaker you appear to be rude.
- krapp 7y agoI'm not trying to be rude, but I honestly believe a lot of the complaints people make about how useless Google's search results seem overblown. I use Google all the time, sometimes for obscure results, often for technical stuff, and the worst I've ever had to do is look past the first page, but often the first page suffices. Google showing results for director's commentary of God of War when someone searches "Lord of War director's commentary" is arguably not a failure on Google's part if more people do search for the game than the movie, regardless of the incorrect title. That said, I completely agree with the theses of TFA. SEO is a cancer.
- scollet 7y agoThey aren't being rude, just increasing the sample size and reporting back. Perhaps we're witnessing SEO for different regions, regulations, and aggregate history of the two.
- krapp 7y agoGoogle usually shows a link to "search for x instead" when that happens. And let's be fair, most people searching for "Lord of War" are probably really searching for "God of War." Having to click an extra link or maybe scroll beyond the front page doesn't make Google a shit show.
- blunte 7y agoPerhaps Google believed that nobody would intentionally look for a Nicolas Cage movie...?
- greggman3 7y agoWhy? He's an academy award winning actor who is hugely popular or else he'd be out of a job.
- uk_programmer 7y agoLord of War is a pretty decent movie.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]