23 ms·
Science -> Engineering -> Technology Technology is applied engineering, and engineering is applied science. The study of types may fall into some field of sci
by 29athrowaway 7y ago
Science -> Engineering -> Technology
Technology is applied engineering, and engineering is applied science.
The study of types may fall into some field of science. Applying it is engineering.
- tsimionescu 7y agoThe study of types is generally done as part of mathematics, not sciences. There are some attempts to study type system impact in real world programs, and ergonomics, which would fall under science, but these are a very small part of PLT. However, the point of the article was different - the article was claiming that when you are writing the actual code for your program, you are normally using engineering-style reasoning (abduction), whereas when you are defining the hierarchy of types for your system, you are mainly applying scientific-style reasoning (induction). Personally, I think that the article is a gross over-simplification of every single term - of deduction, abduction, and induction; of maths, science, and engineering; and of what programmers actually do. It is in fact so over-simplified that I don't see any valuable insight into the article at all. It almlst reads like a description of programming from a TV show that is trying to sound brainy.
- jonnypotty 7y agoI can write types = I'm doing science. I can write code = I'm doing engineering. I'm sure that feels good for lots of people. "trying to sound brainy" - totally agree. this is ultimately the aim of so many attempts to show insight by defining or redefining terms - even if the the people involved don't know it. It's because acidemics and intellectuals have to have ways to evelate themselves above ordinary folk, and usually they do this with language. We can see how important this has become in computing when you look at how important the words you use are. God forbid you use the wrong term, say container when you should be saying entity and oooo, bad programmer - why? Because we don't actually know what makes a good programmer so we have to rely on these cultural language indicators. What was a nontrival programming problem that was solved by applying these ideas? I'd be interested in that. Somehow I suspect this doesn't exist.
- treeman79 7y agoSeen type systems cripple a team before. Less stupid compiler errors. Far more logic bugs. Typescript specifically. But web pages are a different mindset than most domains.
- jonnypotty 7y agoHow do you see the mindset being different?
- treeman79 7y agoArtsy programmers vs functional programmer.
- seemslegit 7y ago> Technology is applied engineering Why not the other way around ?