3 ms·
None of that, while distasteful seems to signal any national security or personal security risk. This seems pretty hyperbolic. Why on earth would the Chinese go
by arcticbull 7y ago
None of that, while distasteful seems to signal any national security or personal security risk. This seems pretty hyperbolic. Why on earth would the Chinese government want access to videos of children in bedrooms? Ridiculous.
- simonh 7y agoThere are two vulnerabilities in particular that can grant access to videos to hostiles. One is that Zoom video chat IDs are short enough and low enough entropy to be guessable. Also saved videos have a standard naming scheme that makes their file names guessable and therefore accessible publicly. However, any vulnerability, especially intentional ones knowingly trading convenience for security or implemented deceptively, is not acceptable especially when we're dealing with the privacy of children.
- valuearb 7y agoThat's a pretty silly concern when photos and videos of the same children are spread across Facebook and other platforms willy nilly.
- simonh 7y agoThose are photos and videos they have intentionally shared. Not supposedly secure private video sessions. If private chats and videos on Facebook of e.g. teenage girls virtual sleepover parties were also trivially accessible by strangers, that would also be an equal concern.
- est31 7y agoThere are more reasons to not give access than personal or national security. Privacy is one. We shouldn't be in a situation where you need to explain why you need privacy. It should be the default.
- arcticbull 7y agoI don't disagree, I'm just tired of the (in this case blatant) "but think of the children" in situations where it's totally irrelevant.
- simonh 7y ago"Think of the Children" is when an issue that is only tangentially or tenuously anything to do with children, and may not even be a legitimate concern anyway, uses a notional impact on children as emotional leverage to gain undeserved attention. This case is literally and specifically about the protection of specific children from a proven risk.
- arcticbull 7y agoIs the proven risk that China is snooping on American children? If so, I'm sure I'd have read it everywhere. If not, it's sensationalism. The case is literally and specifically about Zoom having the ability to snoop. Children are ancillary.
- simonh 7y agoI'll reluctantly repeat the below from another post of mine on this thread: There are two vulnerabilities in particular that can grant access to videos to anyone. One is that Zoom video chat IDs are short enough and low enough entropy to be guessable so it's possible to crash meetings. Also saved videos have a standard naming scheme that makes their file names guessable and therefore accessible publicly, as anyone who knows the file name can access any saved video. Both of these are deliberate choices. They made meeting IDs short and memorable, which makes them guessable. They also wanted saved videos to have meaningful names derived from meeting and user metadata, but again that means they are guessable, and easy to access without annoying security controls.
- valuearb 7y agoWhat "proven risk" is that?
- thawaway1837 7y agoCan you imagine the lawsuits that are gonna come pouring in because some hacker was able to control the webcam on a students MacBook because Zoom’s installer basically acts as an insecure root kit, and takes videos of a kid in his private moments and releases them to the internet?
- valuearb 7y agoNo one has hacked their installer.