3 ms·
The subsidy is in the form of a shared currency, and Germany is the primary beneficiary. With Germany running a large current account surplus, its currency shou
by barrkel 16y ago
The subsidy is in the form of a shared currency, and Germany is the primary beneficiary. With Germany running a large current account surplus, its currency should be appreciating drastically, and that of its trading partners depreciating. Because the currency is shared, and the exchange rate locked in, this can't happen, so in effect Germany is running a mercantilist beggar-thy-neighbour strategy.
- JanezStupar 16y agoBut since Italy, Spain and Greece run the same currency - why don't they use the same strategy? Are you saying that they are more "ethical" and don't have the stomach for such an evil deed? Edit: I apologize to readers and commenters - I got out of context, I'm not referring only to the current monetary/fiscal position of Germany, but to the whole process that got everybody where they are.
- danssig 16y agoBecause they don't have a surplus? The issue is multiple drastically different economies trying to use the same currency. All the reasons you try to appreciate or depreciate your currency are not available to most EU countries.
- JanezStupar 16y agoThis is not only a fiscal issue. This ruin was in the making for decades. While germans were busy figuring out how to produce better stuff for cheaper PIIGS were busy figuring out how to sell shit for more. One strategy is hard short term, but bears long term dividends - the other is awesome short term but spells ruin in the long term and the ruin came. And now the Germany is at fault for all the years of support, encouragement, warnings and leading by example to these countries? I don't buy it :)
- barrkel 16y agoYou're right that it's not only a fiscal issue; it's a monetary issue. Ireland was ruined by low German-style interest rates making money far cheaper than it was before; that fueled a property bubble. The gains to Ireland from 1990-2000 or so were real; the Celtic Tiger wasn't hype. Much of the gains in the past decade, however, were from too low an interest rate.
- barrkel 16y agoThey cannot all run current account surpluses with one another; it's a mathematical impossibility. Germany's current account surplus with other Euro-zone members corresponds exactly to a current account deficit; the sum of the two is zero in this zero-sum game.
- fauigerzigerk 16y agoThe monetary union is voluntary and some European nations used it to load up on cheap debt that they are now asking the Germans to help pay down. Using a common currency always means that interest rates and exchange rates will not be equally appropriate for everybody. It's the same in the US.
- barrkel 16y agoThe debt was cheap because the interest rate was too low. The ECB ran rates low to help Germany's sclerotic economy, and those low rates fueled borrowing elsewhere. As to the idea that the monetary union was voluntary: the monetary union was a political project, not an economic one. By opting out, nations were to some degree dissenting against the entire EU project. Without some degree of fiscal union, it was probably a mistake; but it's unlikely such a union could have ever occurred without a monetary crisis. In many ways, the monetary union was a leap of faith into greater union, with the idea that we could sort out the problems later (never let a good crisis go to waste, etc.).
- fauigerzigerk 16y agoBut it has always been the Germans who kept asking for higher interest rates and a harder currency. The monetary union, as you surely know, does not include the UK, Denmark or Sweden. That's because these countries opted out. No one forced the Greek into the MU. They cheated their way into it by falsifying their accounts.
- barrkel 16y agoYou are simply wrong. I remember the discussion over Greece at the time - about how extra leeway was made to squeeze Greece in a couple of years late. Everybody knew about it. The explicit extent of it was in the news not long after: Sep 2004 http://euobserver.com/?aid=17351 http://euobserver.com/?aid=17351 : "Greece was in breach of the euro rules at the time it joined the single currency, according to new figures produced today by the Greek government." Re Germany - it was at risk of deflation! German politicians were constantly moaning about how high ECB rates were, and how they had to be lowered, and that was the wide consensus of economists too: Apr 2003 https://www.economist.com/node/1695123 https://www.economist.com/node/1695123 : "Most economists agree interest rates are too high for Germany" Jun 2003 http://www.wsws.org/articles/2003/jun2003/doll-j04.shtml http://www.wsws.org/articles/2003/jun2003/doll-j04.shtml : "German Finance Minister Hans Eichel said that the strong euro gave the ECB the opportunity to cut interest rates" Apr 2004 http://www.economist.com/node/2608090 http://www.economist.com/node/2608090 "Even if Mr Schröder does not get the interest-rate cut he wants [...]" Aug 2004 http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/2893715/Economic-agenda-Is-the-euro-forging-a-unified-Europe.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/2893715/Economi... "It is widely appreciated that rates haven't been cut far or fast enough for Germany." No-one forced Germany into the monetary union either...