4 ms·
A conlang designed to be minimal and thus super easy to learn. Why on Earth would one then make a unique character/glyph set? Any conlang that does not fit nea
by sneak 7y ago
A conlang designed to be minimal and thus super easy to learn.
Why on Earth would one then make a unique character/glyph set? Any conlang that does not fit neatly into 8859-1 is a nonstarter for wide adoption.
The “you can write it in latin or in hieroglyphics” aspect of TP seems insane and contradictory to me. That’s the opposite of minimalism.
- jan_Inkepa 7y agoMinimalism is one side, but having fun is another side. Having a small number of words also lends itself a lot to hieroglyphic systems - people love inventing new writing systems (also number systems...) for it.
- sneak 7y agoI think by sticking to latin1, adding directional words and arabic numerals officially, this could stand to be a major global auxiliary language, with all the associated human benefits. Fragmenting the readership and writership with an alternate writing system robs it of that potential, in my view. I like your device and post, fwiw. I just think that languages are a tragic waste if they are not used and learned, and fragmentation harms both of those.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- thesuperbigfrog 7y agoBlissymbols (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blissymbols https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blissymbols) were created to address such a need. Radiolab has a great episode (https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/bliss https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/bliss) that gives the backstory of the creation of Blissymbols and why they did not get as widely adopted as their creator hoped.
- Cyberdog 7y agoIt's a noble idea, but a problem with writing-only constructed languages is that they can only map one-to-one for natural languages if the word order is the same. The example sentence in that article is a good mapping to the English form of the sentence "I want to go to the theatre," but what if your native language is Japanese and you're used to saying "theatre to want to go" (with the personal pronoun implied)? You have to learn new rules about word ordering in sentences, and at that rate you might as well go ahead and learn the full new language. Perhaps Bliss has considered this issue and has an answer for it (can the symbols be written in any order according to the writer's native language?) but I don't see a solution for it mentioned in that Wikipedia article.
- flatline 7y agoI’ve been learning it over the last week or so since I saw it pop up here. I think it could make a worthwhile pidgin for people without a common language, it is so simple. The heavy contextual dependence and simplicity make it harder to justify as a language proper. We are so complex in our modern cultures, and toki pona is so simple! That was the point, after all - “pona” means both good and simple. I haven’t yet seen non-english speakers really using it online but I admit to not looking all that hard.
- whatshisface 7y agoTP has a roman alphabet, that is what the blog post was written in.
- yaktubi 7y agoIs that like an ancient Roman language?
- cjohnson318 7y agoAn alphabet isn't a language.
- yaktubi 7y agoI mean on the website dumbass.
- c3534l 7y agoIt's not a conlang in the sense that anyone expects it to be taken up as an international auxiliary language. It's a conlang created for creative and artistic purposes. It's not meant for "wide adoption." It's meant for fun.
- sneak 7y agoThe cost/benefit ratio of investing the time to learn a new language goes up as the number of people with whom you can speak it increases. Even for fun.
- aidenn0 7y agonitpick, I think you mean the cost/benefit ratio goes down, as the cost remains fixed and the benefit increases?
- sneak 7y agois 1:10 to 1:500 not an increase in ratio? do i have it backwards?
- aidenn0 7y agoThe former is 0.1 the latter is 0.002
- sneak 7y agoMy cursory research on the topic suggests that while the ratio itself is a fraction, the "size" of the ratio refers to the inverse: the magnitude of difference between numerator and denominator, with 1:1 being the lowest ratio. This seems to be more of a linguistic thing than a math thing, which makes this thread on-topic again. :D
- aidenn0 7y agoIf we are going to talk linguistics, then saying "the cost/benefit ratio improves" is probably more clear than saying it gets larger or smaller then.
- knolax 7y agoI find your opinion regarding the Latin Alphabet to be very common in conlang communities. However, I have to disagree with this sentiment. I have not in years encountered a system that does not use some sort of Unicode as its character set, a character set that includes multiple dead languages. From my experience it is possible to create a custom font (in the private use space) + input method for a conscript in a single day. In addition, this idea that latin1 has more universal computer support in legacy and low power systems is unfounded. There are likely far more systems in use today that only support Shift JIS[1] than only support latin1. If you look at actual low power hardware such as this commonly used LCD display[0] you will find that it does not fully support latin1 but does fully support Katakana. Technical concerns aside, as an English speaker I can't even name some of the characters in latin1 like å and ã, let alone type the more exotic ones, so I'm not sure about accessibility. [0] https://www.sparkfun.com/datasheets/LCD/ADM1602K-NSW-FBS-3.3v.pdf https://www.sparkfun.com/datasheets/LCD/ADM1602K-NSW-FBS-3.3... [1]https://softwareengineering.stackexchange.com/questions/82396/what-issues-lead-people-to-use-japanese-specific-encodings-rather-than-unicode/82397 https://softwareengineering.stackexchange.com/questions/8239...