3 ms·
> it is propaganda to count a company's properly profits earned in a foreign country and where proper taxes were paid in that country as somehow evading US taxe
by triceratops 7y ago
> it is propaganda to count a company's properly profits earned in a foreign country and where proper taxes were paid in that country as somehow evading US taxes.
Is it though? US citizens and tax residents (green card holders, people on work visas) pay US taxes on their worldwide income. Doesn't matter if it's earned outside the US. Doesn't matter if the person lives outside the US and hasn't set foot on American soil in decades. Doesn't matter if the income is derived from property acquired before the person ever came to America.
At best they get credit for foreign taxes paid and if that's less than their US tax liability, they pay the difference to Uncle Sam.
Why are the rules (seemingly) different for corporations?
- WalterBright 7y agoThose taxes are unjust and unfair. Applying that to corporations would make them noncompetitive in the global economy. Be careful what you wish for.
- triceratops 7y ago> Applying that to corporations would make them noncompetitive in the global economy. Why? It would apply to all corporations doing business in the US, which is basically any company of note.
- afiori 7y agoThe natural reaction should just be to stop taxing citizens on worldwide income. One reason that could explain the difference between corporate and private taxes is that the companies can (in theory) prove how and where went/came from.
- WalterBright 7y agoIt would give a huge advantage to foreign companies. It would strongly discourage investment in US companies.
- triceratops 7y agoPlease read my comment again. It would apply to every corporation doing business in the US. Regardless of where they're headquartered. And any corp of significance has to do business in the US - it's the largest market in the world.
- nickpp 7y agoThen wouldn’t other countries immediately retaliate with the exact same tax, but applied to American companies doing business in those countries?
- triceratops 7y agoTrue. But they'd also have to raise their tax rates to American rates, for the taxes to have any effect.