2 ms·
The MtGO game was constrained by remaining backwards compatible with the table-top game, overlaid with that damn fool idea about exchanging the virtual and real
by jacques_chester 16y ago
The MtGO game was constrained by remaining backwards compatible with the table-top game, overlaid with that damn fool idea about exchanging the virtual and real cards[1]. That it worked at all is basically a software engineering miracle.
For me the real challenge, when going from tabletop games to computer games, is that in a table game it is trivial to have a rule-modifying rule; in a computer this is a source of substantial complexity.
Think about it: most of the player genius in CCGs is deck construction. That is, studying the rules, studying the cards, and mentally simulating the interaction of multiple rule changes.
Most computer games don't have rule-changing rules, or very few of them due to the cost of special-case coding. They generally resemble CRUD databases with some element of chance applied.
To me the central, and interesting, challenge for a computerised CCG is to capture that rule-modifying rule capability. This might be an area where the dynamism of Lisp is perfectly suited.
[1] It reminds me in retrospect of that camera Kodak produced which took film pictures, but had a screen on the back to show you what you'd taken. That is, a self-defeating and half-hearted attempt to deal with a disruptive change to a fat, profitable industry.
- gamble 16y agoWith a highly profitable paper card business, Wizards has always been concerned with cannibalizing paper sales and pissing off the physical card distributors. MtGO players are largely also paper card players - in particular, the intensely competitive ones who are willing to pay $4 per virtual booster for an online venue to test out competition decks - so matching the paper rules was essential. At the same time, the way they avoided problems with the paper distributors was to cater to the hard-core players and ignore the casual market. TL;DR: Wizards is too dependent on paper card sales to design a next-gen online TCG.
- jacques_chester 16y agoYou are absolutely correct about their position, which reminds me very much of Kodak throughout the 90s. Kodak was tied to film. Even though their own staff foresaw digital photography, they were bound by their own economics and basically wished for digital to go away -- hence their heartbreakingly ridiculous Advantix Preview (the hybrid film/digital camera I mentioned above).