3 ms·
>its ownership is not declared and is hidden behind all kinds of layers of obfuscation This is another form of unnecessary doubt that comes out from laziness
by nabla9 7y ago
>its ownership is not declared and is hidden behind all kinds of layers of obfuscation
This is another form of unnecessary doubt that comes out from laziness from your part and jumping into conclusions.
The ownership of the site is clearly declared in the About section and I mentioned it. EU East Stratcom Task Force part of The European External Action Service (EEAS). EEAS is the diplomatic service and combined foreign and defence ministry of the European Union (EU). https://eeas.europa.eu/ https://eeas.europa.eu/
- jacquesm 7y agoSo it says. But: no address, no official contact, no link to any official EU offices and so on. If this is an EU official effort they are doing a piss-poor job of making their credentials public. Note the "official website of the EU" at the top of every official EU website notice and that that one does not have that banner. "All official European Union website addresses are in the europa.eu domain." I could set up a website within the .eu domain easily enough and link it to all kinds of EU official sites to give it a semblance of officialdom. Add a couple of flag banners and before you know it you're in business. Interesting reading on that site here: https://euobserver.com/opinion/141458 https://euobserver.com/opinion/141458 The lack of transparency is rather interesting. I also note you side stepped the other part of my comment.
- nabla9 7y ago> no address, no official contact, no link to any official EU offices and so on Maybe you should read more carefully and not just skim in hurry. All the above is false. >I also note you side stepped the other part of my comment. Because I largely agree with it. No need to comment.
- jacquesm 7y agoI read very carefully. I'm sure that the site is legit, I am just pointing out that they do a piss poor job of documenting that, are not transparent about their methods, criteria, associates and so on and do not have an official location or any oversight body or review process associated with them (as they ought to have). This makes them part of the problem, not part of the solution, it is essentially a blacklist without a transparent process for adding or removing entries which makes it very useful to achieve the opposite of what it purports to stand for. If the EU is going to do something like this it should be done properly, not in a half-assed and shady way like this because they are lowering the bar for what an official approach to a problem like this should be.
- nabla9 7y agoYou made also incorrect factual claims. Not just claims about them doing qualitatively poor job.
- jacquesm 7y agoDid I now? Such as? "no address, no official contact, no link to any official EU offices and so on" Is absolutely 100% supported by the evidence: the website you linked to. Their official contact is not any address that follows the EU address format, there is no street address, the official EU domain is not used, there is no link to any entity that could be contacted regarding the functioning of that website as is normal for anything EU related. They are as close to a rogue entity as I've seen that is sponsored by the EU to date, and this is exactly how it should not be done, especially for an entity that is effectively able to censor news agencies, a very dangerous and responsible job.
- nabla9 7y agoI'm not going to debate with you anymore. I just copy paste this address I copy pasted from the 'Contact us' page: EEAS Rond-point Robert Schuman 9, 1046 Bruxelles, Belgia
- jacquesm 7y ago> I'm not going to debate with you anymore. That's fine. > I just copy paste this address I copy pasted from the 'Contact us' page: > EEAS > Rond-point Robert Schuman 9, 1046 Bruxelles, Belgia Which does not show for me on that contact page, neither does it on the 'about' page. A 'view source' does not contain that information either. So I'm not sure where you got it off that page but I can't find it. I'd expect a regular format EU contact page, with the address in normal text, which this website does not follow. Conditioning people to accept EU official information from websites that do not follow the EU house-style, live on different domains and in general disavows being "an official EU position" is simply wrong.
- DanBC 7y agoMaybe clicky the search box on the official EU website? https://eeas.europa.eu/headquarters/headquarters-homepage/search/site/euvsdisinfo_en?search_token=o723U8OfUGuCIx6p-1rePhvLcUTgHe1WG3IBGatQGxA https://eeas.europa.eu/headquarters/headquarters-homepage/se... See this news article: https://eeas.europa.eu/headquarters/headquarters-homepage/32408/dont-be-deceived-eu-acts-against-fake-news-and-disinformation_en https://eeas.europa.eu/headquarters/headquarters-homepage/32...
- jacquesm 7y agoYes, I know. The point is - in case it isn't abundantly clear yet - that that website does not itself follow the EU official format: an europa.eu web address, no address for the office it is run out of, the normal banner at the top, transparency in who runs the office, what its mandate is, what process is being used to place entities on the list, what appeals process there is and so on. It is as shady as it gets within the EU. Note that they totally undermine everything they do by stating "Not official EU position". If this is the best we can do against disinformation we're fucked, besides the fact that it only focuses on Russia whereas China and the United States are also quite active in this respect.