4 ms·
> You can find plenty of Windows only successful software that is massively profitable. Where is the same software for Android? The software that is Windows-on
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> You can find plenty of Windows only successful software that is massively profitable. Where is the same software for Android?
The software that is Windows-only isn't the most successful stuff that everybody has heard of (e.g. Office, Adobe, Chrome), that's the stuff available for both because it has enough demand to justify development even for smaller platforms.
The Windows-only applications are the ones with a niche. It's the control application for some piece of industrial equipment, or some line-of-business application, and then you need Windows because you have that equipment or you're in that line of business. And it's the same thing for Android. They can only justify development for one platform so they choose the most popular one. They're just not apps you'll have heard of if you aren't in that niche.
It's even moreso for Android because many types of applications are prohibited by Apple. Like what's the best BitTorrent app for iPhone? File manager? Remote desktop? Screen recording?
Even the popular apps that exist on both platforms aren't as good on iOS. Firefox has to use Safari under the hood. Maybe that doesn't matter to you. Until the "Firefox" you want to run is Tor Browser, which is designed to resist client fingerprinting in ways that Safari isn't, and then the inability to use that on iOS compromises your security. Similarly, the way Signal does backups on Android (i.e. with its characteristically diligent security properties) isn't allowed on iOS, so it doesn't support backups on iOS at all. So even for apps that exist on both, on iOS they're not as good.
- scarface74 7y agoIt's even moreso for Android because many types of applications are prohibited by Apple. Like what's the best BitTorrent app for iPhone? File manager? Remote desktop? Screen recording? There are plenty of Remote Desktop apps for the iPhone. There are also screen recording apps for the iPhone - there is an API for it. It’s used by Zoom. What policies are in place that don’t allow Signal to do backups using its own service - something that other apps do? And seeing how Signal does “backups”. It’s not exactly user friendly (https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007059752-Backup-and-Restore-Messages https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007059752-Ba...) And you’re worried about “security” but you want a File Browser to have unfettered access to your data? It’s a feature that third party apps can only access files outside of their own sandbox that you explicitly give them permission to. No company wants to deal with the hassle and legality of bit torrent. Most people aren’t using to “download Linux ISOs”. I’m definitely not. But before as far as bit torrent, my use case is starting and downloading things on my computer from my phone and adding them to my Plex library. I can do that by pairing my mobile browser to Vuze and going to remote.vuze.com. There are plenty of Windows only consumer apps - especially games. Even from Microsoft, Access and Publisher are Windows only and are included with Office 365.
- leetcrew 7y ago> No company wants to deal with the hassle and legality of bit torrent. counterpoint: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.delphicoder.flud&hl=en_US https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.delphicode...
- scarface74 7y agoGoogle doesn’t even want to deal with the hassle of a well maintained marketplace. Android has five times the marketshare of iOS and makes less money. It seems like Apple’s strategy is working better for consumers and app developers...
- jjeaff 7y agoNo, Apple just has better marketing and has managed to make their products popular amongst the wealthiest people.
- scarface74 7y agoRight because Google - the number one most visited page on the internet has a lesser ability to market than Apple. What do you think made Chrome so popular? People have been saying that marketing is the only reason that Apple is successful since the iPod. Are other companies that incompetent that they could figure marketing out in almost 20 years?
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> There are plenty of Remote Desktop apps for the iPhone. Not screen sharing, something equivalent to Windows Remote Desktop Services or X11 forwarding, where your device acts as a thin client for an application running on a remote server. It's expressly prohibited by the Apple guidelines, presumably because any such client would allow someone to compete with the app store by using remote apps. But it's also useful for other things, like keeping all your data on your company's trusted servers instead of on a device that could be lost or stolen. > What policies are in place that don’t allow Signal to do backups using its own service - something that other apps do? It doesn't use a service because the entire point is to not have all your data in the hands of a third party service. On Android it stores the backup in the filesystem which you copy off the device via USB. > And you’re worried about “security” but you want a File Browser to have unfettered access to your data? It’s a feature that third party apps can only access files outside of their own sandbox that you explicitly give them permission to. "It's not a bug, it's a feature!" There should obviously be a permission required to do that, but if the user wants to use the app to view their files, they should be able to use the app to view their files. This is the problem with Apple deciding everything for everybody. Some people have really stringent security requirements and don't want their data getting uploaded to a service, someone else wants a copy of all the data from every app to be backed up to some third party cloud service. But Apple restricts things to such an extent that you can't choose to do either one. One size fits none. > No company wants to deal with the hassle and legality of bit torrent. Most people aren’t using to “download Linux ISOs”. I’m definitely not. BitTorrent is not illegal, that isn't Apple's problem any more than it is with anything else anyway (what if someone pirates movies with Safari?), and "no company wants to deal with that hassle" is exactly the problem with putting the decision of what you can use your device for in the hands of a third party that isn't responsive to your needs. > But before as far as bit torrent, my use case is starting and downloading things on my computer from my phone and adding them to my Plex library. I can do that by pairing my mobile browser to Vuze and going to remote.vuze.com. Which is a fully generic counterargument, because you can make any app a web page and then do whatever you want on the web page. That's a total cheat when you're asking for things there are no iOS apps for. > There are plenty of Windows only consumer apps - especially games. There are plenty of Android only games, like Doom 3. Not to mention all of the games that can be played in emulators on Android but not iOS because Apple doesn't allow emulators. > Even from Microsoft, Access and Publisher are Windows only and are included with Office 365. You must realize the equivalent to this would be Google apps for Android that don't exist on iOS, which there are several of.