2 ms·
You're right, they didn't necessarily belong to someone else, because "belong" is a useless term. I'm talking about who produces value and who didn't, and my ra
by sudosysgen 7y ago
You're right, they didn't necessarily belong to someone else, because "belong" is a useless term. I'm talking about who produces value and who didn't, and my rationale is that getting a lot of value you didn't produce is immoral, which is ultimately a subjective statement but one I can defend. But because they didn't create a billion dollars in value, then someone else had to produce it. Meaning that someone provided value but got less than what they provided so that a billionaire got more than the value they provided. This is a consequence of the premise that they didn't create a billion dollars in value. I'm saying that it's a diversion, because they contributed less, yet got much more. So in my view, since people who contribute more deserve more, up to a limit on both ends, and that billionaires get much much more than they contribute, being a billionaire means taking what someone else deserves. Which if you agree I think can be fairly called diversion.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoHere's how it looks to me. Wealth often (though not always) comes from increased productivity. That usually looks like new tools or techniques making people more productive. That new productivity creates more money. When that happens, the workers that know how to use the tools deserve some of that new money, because they are now producing more. But also, the one who bought the tools gets part of the money, and so does the one who makes the tool. (If you think that the workers deserve all the new money, then nobody bothers to buy the new tool, so there's no new money. Who does that help?) So the one who buys the tools in fact needs to get some of the money from the new productivity. He's not taking what "belongs" to the workers, because the workers don't deserve all the money, because without the new tools there isn't any new money. The contribution of the billionaires, then, is precisely that they bought the new tools that enabled the new productivity that produced the new money that the billionaires collected part of. Now, you can cite me plenty of examples where this is abused - where the billionaires take most of the money, and the workers get to keep having a job and nothing more. That's wrong. But it's also at least counterproductive to say that the billionaires/investors/capitalists don't get paid back for buying the tools. (I would argue that it's more than counterproductive; it's immoral. But at a minimum, it's counterproductive.)