3 ms·
As someone who really really hates the "reduce contrast" trend, I personally thought the screenshot labeled "have to do better than this" was the most readable.
by userbinator 7y ago
As someone who really really hates the "reduce contrast" trend, I personally thought the screenshot labeled "have to do better than this" was the most readable. The one after that just looks faded.
Then again, I also find it funny that "dark mode" is heralded as something revolutionary, when long ago people could customise UIs far more. You can still do that with userstyles, another thing that seems to have gotten mostly ignored these days...
- zzo38computer 7y agoI agree, I prefer the high contrast too. I also agree about customization, I would suggest using proper CSS classes and HTML and so on in order to allow better user customization with user styles and stuff like that, rather than relying on the service provider. Web pages without CSS can use the settings (for colours, font sizes, etc) specified by the user, so someone should not complain about the lack of CSS, and more so too you should not use CSS too much on web pages I think. (But if you do, ensure you do not do it wrong; if you set the foreground colour you must also set the background colour and vice versa. But don't specify colours at all unless you need to use multiple colours in your document.)
- endorphone 7y agoI don't think anyone heralded it as revolutionary. It's an affordance to the reality that it's a different experience using devices in darkness than in brightness. Mobile screens make dark situations more prevalent. As to UI customization, often that was an inconvenient cop out not a great enabler. "We don't want to figure this out so just change things yourself, but then you'll switch PCs or reinstall and you'll lose all of those customizations and you'll never do it again and you will forever leave everything vanilla". Is it worth websites making a big deal about? No, not really... At most it should put a little badge when it detects the dark mode CSS allowing unwilling users to disable it, but it doesn't seem like something that gets dragged on as long as it has by a couple of sites.
- blt 7y agoI agree - it has a nice high contrast and I didn't really see any significant flaws.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> I personally thought the screenshot labeled "have to do better than this" was the most readable. The one after that just looks faded. Hm. I like the "better" one more. However, it's cheating -- the first screenshot displays a lot of white text in the filters and the text of the questions. The text of the questions is most of what I find off-putting about the first screenshot. The second screenshot displays no white text at all. The filters menu isn't visible. The text of the questions isn't visible. Text that's gray in the second screenshot is also gray in the first screenshot. What kind of comparison is this?
- marksomnian 7y agoIt's because the first two are actually not a comparison. The first image is a screenshot of author's first attempt, while the second is a designer's (maybe the author's?) mockup. For an accurate comparison, compare the first and last screenshots in the article.
- sdegutis 7y agoI very much miss the system theming of Windows XP era. Sure it often looked like crap but sometimes it was great too. Maybe it’s just nostalgia though. But I guess we still have that with desktop Linux...... for the trade offs.
- userbinator 7y agoSure it often looked like crap but sometimes it was great too. The important part is that you could change it relatively easily if you didn't like it, but the "modern" trend has been to remove that ability.
- sdegutis 7y agoYeah that's one reason I keep wanting to try desktop linux again. But then I remember how much work it will be to get drivers working reliably and consistently. Also the fact that there's still really no consistency on linux, e.g. certain apps refuse to respect the "theme" and stand out like a sore thumb.
- dehrmann 7y agoI find it funny that it's pitched as helping eye strain and readability when a light background dilates your eyes, improving focus. That and everyone patting themselves on the back for building dark mode.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoMaybe. I find so much white light overwhelming and have used dark styles nearly everywhere for many years. Even with night color shifting the lighter backgrounds feel like overkill
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zozbot234 7y ago> I personally thought the screenshot labeled "have to do better than this" was the most readable. The one after that just looks faded. It looks like they're using the darkest background ("pure" black or nearly so) for code blocks. Seems like a reasonable choice to me, given that the need for clarity is strongest there.
- PunksATawnyFill 7y agoAMEN. You could set up any color scheme you wanted in Windows 3.1, 30 years ago. You could do so in Unix GUIs as well. The vaunted Apple UI was the exception, forcing an inverse color scheme on all users, all the time. They refused to admit the failure of the "screen as a piece of paper" analogy that ascended during the "desktop publishing" rage of the late '80s/early '90s. So now Microsoft inexplicably REMOVED user-definable color schemes from Windows (around the time of Vista, I think), and Apple has clumsily implemented a hard-coded "dark mode." If you're a developer, you know how hideously broken numerous Apple UI controls are now as a result (rendering nearly invisible text and arbitrary background colors). You could spot Web designers and even design tools that didn't know what they were doing when you'd pull up a Web site to find it mostly blank. This meant that the page overrode your system's dark background color with white, but didn't override your white text color. The result, of course, was white text on a white background. Google embarrassingly introduced this defect into the Google News page at some point, rendering all the story abstracts invisible. Good times.
- juped 7y agoNot a dark mode guy but the high contrast mockup actually looks very nice.