3 ms·
> But one mathematician who prefers to be quoted anonymously says that editors and referees handling these papers might have been in a nearly impossible situati
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
> But one mathematician who prefers to be quoted anonymously says that editors and referees handling these papers might have been in a nearly impossible situation. “If the best mathematicians spend time trying to work out what’s going on and fail, how can one referee on his own have any chance?”
I totally disagree. When someone is making extraordinary claims, the burden is on them to go the extra mile to explain their reasoning, none of which Mochizuki has done. The easy decision in this case should be to leave things at the current "default" state unless a higher burden of proof is met.
I think it reflects especially poorly that when confronted with criticisms that Mochizuki just waved the criticisms away with what was basically a "you mere mortals misunderstood my greatness", without taking the effort to engage and explain himself. I'm not in the math community so could be misunderstanding, but that's certainly the sense I got reading this article.
- pixiemaster 7y ago> the burden is on them to go the extra mile to explain their reasoning that’s not how extraordinary math worked in the past
- QuesnayJr 7y agoThey go the extra mile to explain it to other experts. When Perelman produced his proof of the Poincare conjecture, he traveled all over the place explaining his result.