3 ms·
Wouldn't the same be true of eliminating anything in society? If we all went to electric cars, those in the petro industry would suffer. After all, I don't hear
by bdcravens 7y ago
Wouldn't the same be true of eliminating anything in society? If we all went to electric cars, those in the petro industry would suffer. After all, I don't hear anyone in the Bitcoin community decrying the bank jobs when they wax poetic about putting the banks out of business.
- renewiltord 7y agoOh no, we absolutely should allow for people to change. Few things in the world are Pareto-optimal and we should not restrict change to Pareto-optimal things alone. But the comment I responded to said this: > We could cut the energy consumption of bitcoin to zero and the quality of life of everyone would not change at all. Now I'm not one to normally be pedantic, but if we actually treat this non-literally we're faced with an optimization problem: how much is it worth reducing the quality of life of these people to ensure that energy isn't "wasted"? So either you take the statement as a rhetorical flourish, in which case it is an inadequate response that merely relies on emotive appeals. Or you take the statement as literal, in which case it is obviously true. I guessed at a path but perhaps I should have articulated both sides. As it turns out I guessed wrong and you can see from his response that it was just an optimization problem inadequately specified.