10 ms·
I think everyone involved in this project should be ashamed. Energy shouldn't be wasted into bruteforcing sha1 checksums of lists of transactions, a hash of a
by speedgoose 7y ago
I think everyone involved in this project should be ashamed. Energy shouldn't be wasted into bruteforcing sha1 checksums of lists of transactions, a hash of a previous block to have a neat Merkle tree, and random data to find checksums starting with enough zeros. This is so unnecessary when we have global warming and much better things to do with our energy budget.
- solotronics 7y agoPeople have found bitcoin valuable to them. There are a million other things people spend money (energy) on that are just as wasteful if not more. Why not eliminate movie theaters, air conditioning, travel, sports? People should be free to do as they please and this is all enabled by energy.
- speedgoose 7y agoIt's all about finding a balance. Some people think we should reduce our energy consumption but still maintain a good quality of life. We could cut the energy consumption of bitcoin to zero and the quality of life of everyone would not change at all.
- renewiltord 7y agoThat's not true. There are people who are making a living of trading Bitcoin whose lives will deteriorate. Since Bitcoin only functions when it's hard, cutting the energy consumption means cutting the thing. And attempting to control things like this is a whack-a-mole expedition. If you'd like to account for the carbon externalities, then do so. Tax carbon emissions. Proxy by purchases of fossil fuels if you have to. The reason we don't do that is that most people are rampant polluters. They know it, because when you put the numbers up, we know something interesting: most of those attempting to shame others here are rampant polluters, emitting large multiples of the median human's carbon. The truth is you can't maintain the standard of life you're talking about at the emissions necessary. Shame doesn't work here. Only policy. Tax the carbon if that's what you don't like. Tax the sound if that's what you don't like. Tax the land on its value if you think this is an uneconomical use of the land. But shaming is ineffective. You will walk away with the dopamine rush of outrage, having achieved nothing of note.
- bdcravens 7y agoWouldn't the same be true of eliminating anything in society? If we all went to electric cars, those in the petro industry would suffer. After all, I don't hear anyone in the Bitcoin community decrying the bank jobs when they wax poetic about putting the banks out of business.
- renewiltord 7y agoOh no, we absolutely should allow for people to change. Few things in the world are Pareto-optimal and we should not restrict change to Pareto-optimal things alone. But the comment I responded to said this: > We could cut the energy consumption of bitcoin to zero and the quality of life of everyone would not change at all. Now I'm not one to normally be pedantic, but if we actually treat this non-literally we're faced with an optimization problem: how much is it worth reducing the quality of life of these people to ensure that energy isn't "wasted"? So either you take the statement as a rhetorical flourish, in which case it is an inadequate response that merely relies on emotive appeals. Or you take the statement as literal, in which case it is obviously true. I guessed at a path but perhaps I should have articulated both sides. As it turns out I guessed wrong and you can see from his response that it was just an optimization problem inadequately specified.
- speedgoose 7y agoThe people living from Bitcoin are so few that they don't really matter. I'm sure many of them would find another well paid occupation shortly after and I wouldn't be sorry for the ones that would have to reduce the costs of their lifestyle. I do think social shaming is very powerful, but it must be used correctly. Shaming Bitcoin professionals is fine in my opinion.
- renewiltord 7y agoI don't think it will be effective. Are you interested in laying a bet with some time-frame? You don't have to be, but I find that it clarifies my priors appropriately.
- fermienrico 7y agoWhat if I told you that you can use this "useless" BTC to purchase carbon offsets, invest in renewable energy (which otherwise would have no funding), etc? Sure, money has no value when you're stuck on an island, but a bow and arrow does. Similarly, a bow and arrow has little value in Tokyo city and money does. Money is the engine that drives motivation - it can be used to compel others to do good things. Also, people don't understand what Bitcoin mining in wholistic sense is. Model A: Energy -> Factory (Assets) + Labor -> Revenue Model B: Energy -> Mining hardware (Assets) -> Revenue It is surprisingly the same (we can even argue that labor is involved in building mining assets, GPUs don't grow naturally). You can argue that any economic endeavor is a waste.
- paulgb 7y ago> What if I told you that you can use this "useless" BTC to purchase carbon offsets, invest in renewable energy (which otherwise would have no funding), etc? Unless they actually are using it to purchase carbon offsets, I don't see what's the point of this hypothetical? > Also, people don't understand what Bitcoin mining in wholistic sense is. Sure, some Bitcoin critics don't understand it well, but don't paint us all with that brush. Some of us have a very good understanding of what Bitcoin mining is and still find it tremendously wasteful.
- fermienrico 7y agoI think it is just to make a point - that BTC generated from this "wasteful" activity can be used for any purpose. It could pay off executives or the government can use it to propel society forward or offset carbon credits or build warheads. The right or wrong is not in the action of mining BTC, it is the same as any other economic acivity. I've added some more clarity. > Sure, some Bitcoin critics don't understand it well, but don't paint us all with that brush. Some of us have a very good understanding of what Bitcoin mining is and still find it tremendously wasteful. By all means, expand on this and enlighten me, I am curious to hear both sides.
- sixstringtheory 7y ago
- zozbot234 7y agoAnd yet, this "waste" of energy enables a sizeable amount of decentralized positive-sum transactions by actors who don't necessarily trust each other, and cannot always use existing (centralized) systems for this purpose. This is a socially-positive development overall.
- speedgoose 7y agoThankfully Bitcoin isn't the only solution to answer this problem. By the way, the world economy isn't centralized and thankfully doesn't rely on a single database with a shitty and super slow consensus algorithm that destroy the environment, by design.
- OGWhales 7y agoBy design, bitcoin favors the miners with the most efficient equipment and naturally adjusts to advances in these technologies. I think the other concepts are quite interesting as well. But it’s not fair to say bitcoin is design to destroy the environment as it can also drive people to design ever more efficient ways to produce energy.
- T-1000 7y agoWhat would the ransomware industry look like without cryptocurrencies?