4 ms·
> it was later dropped over opposition Both parties make mistakes. Sigh. Why on earth did they frame this as a "bailout for big oil"? It's a strategic concer
by echelon 7y ago
> it was later dropped over opposition
Both parties make mistakes.
Sigh.
Why on earth did they frame this as a "bailout for big oil"? It's a strategic concern for national security.
- rstupek 7y agoBecause anytime you can re-frame whatever your opponent is doing into something negative you win more political points with your base.
- reportingsjr 7y ago> Why on earth did they frame this as a "bailout for big oil"? Because that is exactly what it is. You're talking about the largest companies in the world, they've have decades and decades of war and subsidy supporting them. They don't need more support now, especially considering the environmental destruction they cause. Now is a much better time to push forward higher quality energy production technology like solar, wind, batteries, etc.
- leetcrew 7y agowhy would now, while we're in the midst of a public health crisis and the ensuing economic turmoil, be a good time to radically change our energy infrastructure to something that still has a higher unit cost? I can obviously see that, politically, now is a good opportunity to push agendas that would otherwise not be accepted, but does that really make it a good time overall?
- makomk 7y agoIt's not a good time at all. Even if you put the cost and reliability problems aside for a moment, the entire planet's supply chains are massively disrupted and largely shut down. Plus, even if you could get the equipment manufactured, installing it is a health hazard right now - it means lots of people from all over the place in close quarters on sites with poor access to sanitation facilities. This will set back green energy a year at the very minimum.
- reportingsjr 7y agoLower pollution energies only have a higher unit cost due to insane subsidies that oil/gas/coal receive. Now is a great time to ramp up cleaner technologies since people are going to be looking for jobs anyways once this ends. Much better to advance technology when we are fixing our economy versus propping up old, unhealthy means.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 7y agoYes. But just like various items in demand now ( ventilators, masks and so on ), it is not a bad idea to have a strategic reserve of those for those times when they would be necessary. I am a alternative energy proponent, but it seems misguided to simply ignore current situation and not take steps beneficial to the taxpayer ( buy stuff while it is cheap ). The other side of the argument appears to want to cause maximum amount of pain to force people to move to the other sources. I understand that argument. I do not really buy it. National stockpile should not be subject to that. It serves a strategic purpose. edit: added not before take
- reportingsjr 7y agoThe national reserves are already significantly full. There isn't a huge need to absolutely fill them to the rim considering their size.
- kortilla 7y agoSure there is. Top them off at record low prices and be done with it. Then there won’t be much argument to keep them full. Why build it to the storage capacity it has if we’re not going to fill it?
- briandear 7y agoNow is the worst time. Millions are losing their jobs, the last thing we need is to promote more expensive energy. A steady supply of energy right now is critical to literally keeping the lights on. Imagine our current situation but with more expensive energy costs and an unreliable supply. Like it our not, oil is critical to our survival right now. Cheap, plentiful energy is also going to be essential to driving the recovery. It’s also a strategic necessity.
- godtoldmetodoit 7y agoIt's really not though. Back when the US was a oil importer yes, but under normal market conditions we are the largest exporter in the world. The shale guys can basically flip a switch and go from 0 to millions of BPD. So we are really just paying to move oil from one rock formation to another...
- kube-system 7y agoRight now we can, yes. There's nothing that guarantees that will continue to be the case in the future. If we could accurately predict future changes in market conditions, nobody would ever need stockpiles. If anything, the writing is on the wall for American oil production. The current low prices are mainly a manufactured attempt to bankrupt oil producers with higher overhead costs.
- BurningFrog 7y agoThe ability to start pumping the oil in American soil is not dependent on market conditions. The shale oil in the ground is a perfectly good stockpile as is. Or so it seems to this perhaps overconfident computer guy with little relevant expertise...
- nordsieck 7y ago> The shale oil in the ground is a perfectly good stockpile as is. I think the point people are trying to make is that it's quite a bit less expensive to buy crude and store it right now than to extract it from shale in the future.
- BurningFrog 7y agoSure, but you have to weigh in the probability that such a strategic stockpile will ever be used. As an economic investment, it may well be a real good idea to buy up cheap oil now. But that's separate from the stockpile argument.
- ip26 7y agoWhy on earth did anyone frame 2008 as a "bailout for big banks"? It was a strategic concern for national security. It can be both at the same time.