5 ms·
All over the world houses are built according to available local materials and the degree of weather insulation required, mainly. In America, houses in Maine c
by crazygringo 7y ago
All over the world houses are built according to available local materials and the degree of weather insulation required, mainly.
In America, houses in Maine can be built completely differently from houses in Florida.
The reason we don't build out of stone/brick, besides cost of construction, is that they're terrible insulators. So your heating or AC bill is going to go absolutely through the roof.
A wood frame stuffed with insulation means your home can be energy-efficient. This is a good thing.
We don't fetishize a house being "solid" and we don't generally punch our walls on a regular basis. :) "Solid" sounds like a big waste of money to me.
- enriquto 7y agoThe thing is, the USA is the country with most tornadoes in the world. A solid house with thick walls is tornado-resistant. Yet, you lose thousands of plywood homes per year due to tornadoes, while the rest of the world builds real houses with stone walls just because they are more beautiful. What it seems to me is that you have a weird, unhealthy fetish for paper-thin houses.
- pimlottc 7y agoThere are vast areas of the US that are not generally affected by tornados. It’s a big country.
- vageli 7y ago> The thing is, the USA is the country with most tornadoes in the world. A solid house with thick walls is tornado-resistant. Yet, you lose thousands of plywood homes per year due to tornadoes, while the rest of the world builds real houses with stone walls just because they are more beautiful. What it seems to me is that you have a weird, unhealthy fetish for paper-thin houses. It seems this fetish is spreading. My family is from a fairly small island in the Mediterranean where all the houses are constructed of solid reinforced concrete and foreigners who are buying property for vacation homes have been putting up little timber boxes which are the subject of local gossip.
- djohnston 7y agotornadoes effect a minority of people in the US. population dense centers like california are more likely to succumb to earthquakes, in which case your concrete home is way worse
- clairity 7y agophysics basically--same reason why wings aren't built with high rigidity (or with bricks). brick walls have good downward (and in-line lateral) force resistance and suck at every other direction and torsion. tornado forces are multi-directional. wood frame walls are strapped down to the foundation in earthquake/tornado zones. plywood acts against (some) lateral and torsional forces. plus, flying bricks are more dangerous to squishy humans.
- avmich 7y agoDo you often have flying skyscrapers? Or pieces of concrete during tornadoes? Or even just rocks from mountains? The concrete technology is supposed to be able to achieve similar results. Does it take too much expensive concrete? What numerical comparisons are saying?
- throw149102 7y agoEven if you do live in "Tornado Alley" tornadoes can have a surprisingly limited effect - small tornadoes have the habit of carving small paths in the city, capable of leaving one side of a road pristine and the other destroyed. In either case, building a home out of stone would do very little to stop, say, a refrigerator picked up by the tornado moving at 200 mph. Nor will it stop the house from pressurizing and blowing the roof off, stone or no stone. I mean, it could, if the walls were a foot thick each and there were no windows. As a result, most Americans in the Tornado Alley (who can afford it) have a basement that has stone walls, and just accept the small probability that they lose almost all of their home.
- robin_reala 7y agoRelative to land area, the UK has more tornadoes than the USA (and anywhere else in the world): https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/climate-information/extreme-events/us-tornado-climatology https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/climate-information/extreme-events...
- buckminster 7y agoAs the article notes, the UK's tornadoes are generally weak. It's national news if a single house loses a roof. We don't get massive twisters marching through towns cutting a swathe of destruction.
- eeZah7Ux 7y ago> The reason we don't build out of stone/brick, besides cost of construction, is that they're terrible insulators. So your heating or AC bill is going to go absolutely through the roof. The very opposite. A thin layer of plywood is a terrible insulator. Bricks are very good.
- PaulDavisThe1st 7y agoBricks are actually very poor insulators. A wood-frame house with the framing elements filled with appropriate thicknesses of insulation is a very, very much better insulated structure than one made (only) of brick.
- crazygringo 7y agoI mentioned in another comment, nobody's building houses out of sheets of plywood. (I mean plywood may or may not be involved, but that's not the "wood" part of a "wooden house".) Wooden houses have wooden frames, with the wooden beams spread out, so that the space between them is chock-full of insulation. This insulation is far, far, far superior than brick/stone can ever be. Brick is a terrible insulator. That's just a fact.
- avmich 7y agoThe point in brick/concrete walls is that they are much sturdier and harder to break - voluntarily or involuntarily - than plywood. It sounds like proponents of wooden structures keep forgetting that. For thermal protection you can add the same insulation as for the wooden frame. How those stone houses in New England fare during the year, are they that obsolete in terms of insulation?
- freeone3000 7y agoI can tell you how the stone houses in Quebec fare - they're shit. It's drafty and awful and you have to continually run the heater. Compared to my modern insulated condo with drywall walls and joist-and-beam construction (with a concrete support beam and an entire wall of windows), where I run the heater for maybe 20 minutes a day? It's a difference.
- nitrogen 7y ago"Solid" sounds like a big waste of money to me. It's my experience that our American housing/apartment market is obsessed with pictures and numbers. Square footage. Dazzling photos. Checklists of amenities. And this has been the source of much misery for me. For years I have hunted for somewhere to live with even a modicum of soundproofing. I've tried older duplex buildings with deep basements that are now illegal for fire escape reasons, higher end apartments, standalone houses, ... Nobody advertises based on "soundproofing", with one exception that was ultimately a lie. Nobody advertises based on air system quality. It's like we have completely forgotten that we have any senses other than sight.
- norswap 7y agoI'm sorry but this insulation talk is complete nonsense. Here (Belgium) houses are mostly made of concrete blocks with an insulation filling, then fronted with bricks. No reason why you'd need to use wood to add an insulation layer. Then why is wood more isolating than stone? Have you ever visited a medieval castle in the heat of summer? I guarantee that the thick stone walls offer more insulation than any modern home I've ever visited. Of course, we don't make walls that thick, but the material is not at issue.
- PaulDavisThe1st 7y ago(Background: I live in adobe home, with 24"/ 61cm thick adobe walls in much of the structure). Brick/stone/adobe are not insulators. They have substantial thermal mass, which means that they act to stabilize temperature. Put differently, they create a phase delay between exterior and interior temperatures changes. The problem with this model is that it works in both ways if you live in a climate (like much of the USA) with substantial swings in typical daily temperatures between seasons. The same massively thick stone wall that keeps the medieval castle cool in the heat of summer is also chilled to well below freezing by the deep cold of winter, and turns the castle (or whatever) into an icebox. This is why sensible construction involves both thermal mass (stone/brick/adobe) and insulation. The former helps stabilize temperature, the latter prevents substantial gradients between the structure and the interior (or exterior) from causing major energy flow.
- hindsightbias 7y agoConcrete is not very green or cheap. Stone quarries and transportation for modern suburbia would be very ungreen and expensive. Aerated concrete for walls is a very awesome idea from Europe, but it’s not structural and by the time you build the structure for a typical two storey I’d bet that stick framing would be cheaper. Euros typically put a much higher ratio of their income into housing and are willing to spend more. Same for Japan, and they build very good houses, but then tear them down after a couple of generations.
- crazygringo 7y agoYou don't seem to understand how insulation works (or is necessary) in the US. It's not that wood is super-insulating (though it's certainly better than stone). It's that wooden beams are spread far apart, and the space between them can be chock-full of insulation. And as another commenter pointed out, the main reason isn't summertime insulation -- it's wintertime insulation. Stone is freezing. When it's -20°C out, insulation in between wooden beams makes all the difference. Concrete blocks filled with insulation still just have way too much concrete to transmit the cold directly from outside to inside.
- Bayart 7y ago>The reason we don't build out of stone/brick, besides cost of construction, is that they're terrible insulators. So your heating or AC bill is going to go absolutely through the roof. I'm writing this from a perfectly insulated 200 years old stone house. We've got access to a wide array of insulation technology in Europe, often in the form of panels that can be used to renovate an older building. And you can just blast insulation on the bottom part of a roof, which costs a penny and takes care of a most of your thermal dissipation. Plus insulation is getting subsidized when the government wants to save energy. >"Solid" sounds like a big waste of money to me. Paying for a paper house sounds like a scam to me.
- umvi 7y agoInstead of thinking in hyperbole, think in CS terms: "Solid" houses are "immutable", and "paper" houses are "mutable". I recently redid some plumbing in my "paper" house. It was real easy: shut off the water, cut some dry wall, make the fix, put some drywall back in, plaster, and paint. How would this work in a solid house? Do I need to jackhammer through stone and then mix concrete to seal it back up when I'm done?
- NanoWar 7y agoYep. It's a ton of dirt
- laurencerowe 7y agoPipes tend to be exposed in brick houses so you don’t need to tear the wall down when you have a leak.
- avmich 7y agoYou don't. You really don't need that for years and years in a row. When you need, you do need some tools though. I see we can have all kinds of analogies; I guess habits play a big role here. Different places in USA have different house styles - it's a big country.
- Bayart 7y ago>How would this work in a solid house? I've got copper tubing running along the bottom of the walls and going through inner walls and flooring. I can't think of anything going through the outer walls. We've got an antenna cable routed through a window frame.