5 ms·
I think this is where NASA went wrong in many respects. They got so risk adverse, they built a bureaucracy of checks and oversight that moves slow. That’s one o
by bumby 7y ago
I think this is where NASA went wrong in many respects. They got so risk adverse, they built a bureaucracy of checks and oversight that moves slow. That’s one of thew reasons the industry needs fresh blood like SpaceX
- mcbutterbunz 7y agoTwo reasons and probably more: 1. The risk is different when there are human lives on the line. 2. NASA is publicly funded and if they want to keep receiving funding, they can’t be blowing up the public’s money.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoI feel NASA's approach is right for manned spaceflight, but is not sensible for robotic missions - metal is cheap, design time is expensive. I feel the public appearance is not a hard - nosed calculation, but Is instead a pr requirement
- greglindahl 7y agoNASA has different risk categories for manned spaceflight and robotic missions, depending on cost.
- sbuttgereit 7y agoI actually disagree with you. For one, consider that Starship is ultimately intended for manned spaceflight... yet SpaceX is still trying things and blowing stuff up (or imploding or...) From my armchair perspective I think the risk adversity criticism is justified. NASA should take much more risk even in human spaceflight... in the early stages of platform development. First see if you can build the damn thing and build it repeatedly. Later, after that period, reduce risk and prove out and refine things to the human spaceflight standard. If you jump immediately to, "my God people are suppose to fly on that thing!" well, you're probably going to pay the Russians a lot of money for a fairly long time. I do agree with you that the political management becomes a real issue. Politicians and bureaucrats are naturally disposed to a certain cravenness about such issues once they get to significant positions of power (senior execs of many companies do, too). But I think a charismatic leader that's out in front of the messaging could pull it off.
- kiba 7y agoIf they actually test and launch the damn thing, we would be further along with a safer rocket and don't have to pay the Russians.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoWell, ironically and counter to your point, Russians had the same basic design now for nearly 60 years!
- beamatronic 7y agoWhen a robot mission is wildly successful, they should build more of the design and launch another.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoI think this is a very good point that is frequently overlooked, it would only cost 2x to have 10 rovers instead of one! It is also absolutely embarrassing that we still haven't fully surveyed the moon for resources, dont know where all the ice is, etc. Lunar rovers should be numbering in the hundreds, maybe thousands.
- bumby 7y agoMany of NASAs robotic missions are done through JPL which doesn’t follow all the same rules, but you’re absolutely right about the PR
- nickik 7y agoWell because of that approach NASA lost the ability to do human space flight. They literally couldn't do it, and the admired that they basically can't develop it internally without it costing 10s of billions. So that's why the used the Commercial Crew program and that worked out for them. The SLS is a good example, 10+ years of building at a cost far above 20+ billion until the first launch.
- kiba 7y agoPrototype can and should be tested with the risk of blowing up if they want to improve rockets' reliability. Obviously, there's not much tolerance when human lives on the line. But you don't have to test with humans.
- beamatronic 7y agoThey went too far and aren’t blowing anything up. There has to be an optimal amount of resource burn
- Causality1 7y agoFrankly I'd rather them blow up my money than spend twenty times the original budget and ten times the schedule filling the pockets of companies like Boeing.
- bumby 7y ago1. Keep in mind NASA has multiple Centers and only one (Houston) is dedicated to human-rated spaceflight 2. Dirty little secret: even when NASA uses “startups” like SpaceX to launch and things go awry, the taxpayers are still on the hook for the majority of the loss because the Agency is self-insured
- kiba 7y agoThey got really risk adverse and their vehicles aren't that reliable and safe at the end anyway.
- akiselev 7y agoA JPL project manager teaching a course I took blamed it on the public's "mathematical illiteracy." He explained that there are diminishing returns on mission success rates so NASA often had the choice of paying X per mission attempt each with an 80% success rate or 2X for a single launch with 95% success rate. 80% sounds bad but the chance of two launches failing is 4%, which means a 96% chance overall success rate. If the first launch succeeds, they can usually save between 20-40% of the total budget (the remaining amount is overhead to build backups and keep scientists and engineers employed in case the first launch fails). However, since NASA is no longer doing world shattering stuff like landing on the moon, the human echo chamber amplifies each failure and drowns out the successes. Since NASA has to justify many appropriations on a per project basis, failures lead to projects getting canceled and NASA doing less actual science, even though their budget rarely shrinks - with more and more money instead allocated to inefficiencies like maintaining unused real estate/hardware and spreading out manufacturing across all districts in order to curry favor to get more projects going. That's just for robotic/satellite missions. It's ten times worse when a manned mission ends fatally.
- jeffwass 7y ago> since NASA is no longer doing world shattering stuff like landing on the moon NASA has its Artemis program which is doing exactly this, returning to the Moon with a goal of a longer-term lunar base. And they just held a period of application (it closed a few days ago) for the next generation of Artemis astronauts. Artemis : https://www.nasa.gov/specials/artemis/ https://www.nasa.gov/specials/artemis/
- nickik 7y agoYeah they said they will return to the Moon or Mars (depending on the president) since Bush 1. That is almost 40 years. So another new moon plan. Another Shuttle derived launcher. Not surprising that nobody is getting very exited with Artemis. The SLS and Orion can only be described as dead-weights on NASA since they are so incredibly expensive. SLS has been in development for over 10 years at more then 2 billion per year and it will not launch until 2022 hopefully.
- 7y ago