9 ms·
I don't think people appreciate how many businesses literally go into a death cycle the minute that cash flow is cut by any significant percentage. With this sh
by chrisco255 7y ago
I don't think people appreciate how many businesses literally go into a death cycle the minute that cash flow is cut by any significant percentage. With this shut down, it's like, 90+% of revenue cut off for entire industries. This is going to trigger a series of defaults and bankruptcies that are incalculable. These SBA loans are a bandaid. They won't prevent massive bankruptcies and economic depression if these shut downs continue for any longer.
- generalpass 7y agoMore like a bandaid on a severed artery.
- lalos 7y agoA business that doesn't have cash flow for bad times is not a business. There was a time when business weren't leveraged to the max and the profit taking during good times was not squeezed to every cent. This could easily be fixed with regulation to promote this behavior but currently the priority is to take the profits to the owners.
- generalpass 7y ago> A business that doesn't have cash flow for bad times is not a business. There was a time when business weren't leveraged to the max and the profit taking during good times was not squeezed to every cent. This could easily be fixed with regulation to promote this behavior but currently the priority is to take the profits to the owners. This may be what we read about publicly traded firms, but small businesses are in a completely different category. For example, many of them, if they do not take loans to improve their offering, will lose customers to the competition.
- notyourday 7y agoSo Nike is not a business? Cheesecake Factory is not a business? TJMAXX is not a business?
- throwaway_USD 7y agoNo they are just debtors...once they can't service their debt they are simply insolvent debtors whose assets will be foreclosed on.
- rdtwo 7y agoThose assets are worth pennies on the dollar to a 3rd party and the liquidation process will cut those pennies in half
- jvm_ 7y agoYour local diner probably doesn't have months worth of cash sitting around. They make food, sell it, pay employees and open the doors the next day. That falls apart pretty quickly if people stop buying their food.
- internalthief 7y agoOne of my favorite bagel shops is barely making payroll during this shutdown, and only because they are heavily innovating how they keep customers. They are now offering meal kits, so you get a meal for two to four people in one easy go, they started shipping via USPS, and they are doing local deliveries. They make their own in-house butter, cheese and cream cheese so their kits do fairly well. They are also increasing what other items they are selling, such as adding bread to their lineup. Which is absolutely fantastic. But it's still hard for them, with the reduction in people coming in and sitting around they don't get people buying a bunch of coffee or having breakfast and then lunch while chatting. They have had to furlough some of their staff, and I really hope they make it through, because another favorite restaurant of mine is going under, they simply can't afford to keep going, even with a loan that would help pay salaries, there are other contracts and payables due that simply can't be covered with enough loans... loans against what collateral?
- xeromal 7y agoOne of my favorite bread shops is basically in tears on instagram due to this thing. They've tried a few approaches to improve sales but they're basically closing shop for now.
- remmargorp64 7y agoSo lay off the employees, have them collect unemployment. What are your operating costs? Really just the lease on the building. So don't pay the lease for a couple months. Who suffers? The commercial real estate holder. What are they going to do? Lease it to another restaurant while your doors are closed? So the commercial real estate investor loses out on some profit and/or defaults on their commercial mortgage payment to the bank. Now who is suffering? The bank! But what happens when the big banks don't get their real estate loans paid? They can always just put loan payments on hold for a couple of months, and instead of making $300 billion in profits that year, they make only a measly $100 billion. When it all blows over, the small/medium businesses can re-open and re-hire all of the people back again, and they can all stop taking unemployment. Life continues on as usual. Why should the average person have to suffer so that these big banks can keep charging interest on their loans every month? Why can't we just legally mandate that they have to put the loans on pause and suck it up like the rest of us?
- Anon1096 7y ago>There was a time when business weren't leveraged to the max and the profit taking during good times was not squeezed to every cent Can you cite such a time when businesses, especially small, could survive in a competitive market without taking on debt and redirecting profits to the business? Because this hasn't been true ever. Small businesses need every edge they can get to survive, and that means not having gold-laden chests lying around waiting the the 100-yearly plague to come.
- lalos 7y agoAccounting 101: balance sheets, cash flow analysis. Those tools were not created to have interesting graphs and tables to look at but to promote and show explicitly what’s going on behind the scenes. I get that a lot of people just invest on their emotions (like-able CEO; must invest!) but what’s actually happening is they are just taking in debt and passing on the risk (while profiting temporarily and leaving the company exposed naked). I have tons of friends with small business that own 2-3 personal property, all the luxuries and yet officially the business is in shambles (right now). The attitude is “who cares”, they take the money out and spend it on themselves and just fire everyone. They pass on the risk. That money came from greener days and now employees have to file for unemployment. I guess people see this as normal, but it isn’t and it shouldn’t. Tax-payers are now subsiding those unemployment checks while the profit taking already benefited the owners.
- gamblor956 7y agoThis does not describe most businesses, ever, especially not most small businesses. Small businesses have always lived relatively hand-to-mouth existences, and the "profits" are usually enough to cover the owner's equivalent of a salary.
- tathougies 7y agoThere is a huge difference between 'bad times' and having your business eliminated by government mandate. Even during the recession of 2008, demand didn't go to zero. It is insane to expect anyone, business, individual, or otherwise, to be able to go completely without income for any prolonged period of time.
- majormajor 7y agoYou don't get consumer demand back to its old levels by flipping a magic shutdown switch while the virus is still growing. Competition under our current rules has eliminated the ability of most businesses to save cash or have any real buffer, since they'd lose to the ones that ran month to month right on the edge. Pushing to "end the shutdown" to return things to normal there is a false hope.
- draw_down 7y agoI don't think GP said anything to contradict that. The point is simply that a lot of businesses are screwed.
- runawaybottle 7y agoNo one said it’s going to be a flip of a switch. It will definitely be a prolonged process, but we already saw what 1 month of a shutdown can do. So we have to realize that being 1 month ahead in restarting everything is precious. Society has to get used to the paradigm that 50% are asymptomatic and can return to the economy, while at the same time compromising for the other 50% that need to stay home and quarantine. This is the new reality to pragmatically restart things. Your company should still be remote until end of summer. Businesses should re-open with generous time off for anyone that needs it without laying people off.
- download13 7y agoBut they won't because they would lose out to any businesses that didn't. Almost like competition is really ill-suited to solving public disasters (as well as a lot of other things).
- kbenson 7y ago> Society has to get used to the paradigm that 50% are asymptomatic and can return to the economy, while at the same time compromising for the other 50% that need to stay home and quarantine. Nobody knows who they are until they get infected (and sometimes not even then, if they don't present much). 50% of the people going back and half of them having problems would still completely overflow all our healthcare capacity and many of them would die. The perfect plan would be to massively ramp-up the healthcare system capacity as fast as possible and to fit those that need extra attention to our ability to provide it perfectly. The problems with this are manifold: - The time the professional help is needed is often a week or more after infection and long after they've been contagious, making planning hard. - Knowing how people interact and congregate and spread the disease is essentially unknowable when people are actually interacting, so the only way to have any semblance of forecasting ability is to prevent interactions. - Having surplus capacity by 10% doesn't kill anyone. Having surplus patients you can't handle by 10% means deaths, and at a high percentage rate (I wouldn't be surprised if it's 10% of that cohort or higher). As the capacity ramps up, we're also talking about really large numbers. If we can handle 10 million people in the healthcare system, being off my 10% and having 10% of those die because of it is 100,000 people. - The spread is not even, there will be hot spots that outstrip local capacity while remote capacity is underutilized. Right now we have people afraid, but we don't have a massive panic so much, depending on where you are. Once a lot more people start dying, and people around you that you know, then real panic will start, and that might make any economic problems we're seeing now look tame comparatively.
- throwaway_USD 7y ago>I don't think people appreciate how many businesses literally go into a death cycle the minute that cash flow is cut by any significant percentage. Americans have never seen a debt they didn't think they can borrow their way out of, this is true of individuals, banks and politicians. American capitalism has been replaced by debt, there are no more owners, just holders of debt, this is why your statement rings true. Maybe a witty HNer can coin the term of this failed system of economics.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cwkoss 7y agoI recommend the "Money as Debt" series on youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2nBPN-MKefA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2nBPN-MKefA
- vearwhershuh 7y agoThe insanity is that people pushing to reopen the economy are being called shills for wall street. Elite wall street doesn't care when the economy reopens. They are gonna get bailed out by the Fed no matter what, and the worse it is on main street, the more assets they can buy up at distressed prices. Main street is getting absolutely wrecked right now: barbers, restaurants, mom & pops, etc. Gates can sit in his multi-million dollar compound and talk about how we are gonna have to shut the entire country down for the summer. He is going to be fine, sure. But until he starts talking about how he is helping the average family feed itself he's just an impossibly out of touch elite, and, what is worse, potentially talking his own book.
- dariusj18 7y agoI think the issue is, a) We reopen early, transmissions rates rise again, we have to go through another shutdown, let's say that's another month and a half. b) We wait an extra two weeks, things reopen, no cascade in transmissions. In either case, "Wall street" will do fine, in case (a), "Main street" gets extra dead. (time spans are made up, but the idea that a relapse would be longer I think is solid)
- ahelwer 7y agoIt is impossible to reopen without Taiwan-style temperature checks & mask requirements outside buildings, contact tracing, large-scale testing, and quarantine enforced by penalty of law (with corresponding support systems - get the police to do something useful and bring people groceries). Anything else and we'll be right back in lockdown inside of a month.
- meddlepal 7y agoThen this is all pointless because it will take years to retrofit everything with that level of testing and tracing and make it useful in some way as well as enforcing isolation. We might as well open up and suffer the consequences until we have herd immunity even if that means a lot of deaths.
- m3kw9 7y agoThe fed gonna keep pumping cash, they didn’t run out of ammo yet. In Smb case they may forgive portion of it just again flatten the curve
- Consultant32452 7y agoI think the issue is that when most people think of a "bad week" they mean sales are down 20% or 30%. But no, in this case, the sales are z.e.r.o. It's hard to wrap our heads around if we haven't felt it first hand.
- soneil 7y agoWhat's really kicking a lot of our "main street" business is that they're more or less seasonal. We're very tourist heavy, so revenue spikes in better weather. So they expect to have reserves for the winter, and this is almost perfectly timed to arrive just as they were expecting business to increase. They do prepare for lean times. And they've just had 5 months of lean times. This is not only the worst possible moment for this, it's also quickly writing off the summer season where they'd usually be expected to recoup. That is incredibly difficult to recoup. Small businesses simply don't have a 1-year "war chest".
- tathougies 7y ago> These SBA loans are a bandaid. Why? They're completely forgiven if they keep their employee.s This isn't really a loan, but free money.
- gumby 7y agoAnd if the situation stabilizes after a few months then the bandaid will have worked. If there’s a year or two or more of recovery than the bandaid will have adequate (perhaps another will be possible, perhaps not' who knows)
- aaomidi 7y agoI like how when this happens to companies it's not their fault, but when it happens to people everyone starts berating them for not saving/etc. Like. What? Our economic system is beyond broken if we expect companies to have less fiscal sensibilities than individuals.
- cochne 7y agoSocialism for the rich, and rugged individualism for the poor.
- rpiguy 7y agoIn this case it is not their fault. The government ordered people to stay home and shut the economy down. The government is merely compensating business for its own actions, so people may have jobs to go back to when the restrictions are lifted. In other cases I would totally agree with you. GM never should have been bailed out, and most of the finance companies and banks should have been allowed to go bust in 2008.
- tomp 7y agoWas GM bailed out? I don't think it was... the original company went bankrupt, the government effectively bought it in bankruptcy to preserve jobs (and US car manufacturing capacity), but I though the original shareholders were left with nothing, so not exactly a bailout.
- rpiguy 7y agoTrue. The US government spent 51 billion dollars so the new GM could continue to operate without disruption and continue to pay employees and retirees and took a 61% stake that they eventually sold for 39 billion. So the government lost 12 billion plus the time value of money. The retirees were lucky that the Democrats were in charge. While a republican may have also provided a bail out, they may have forced a true chapter 11 where the retirees’ pensions are reduced to the federal minimum. The new GM would have emerged without the pension liability.
- 7y ago
- 0x8BADF00D 7y agoWell, they shouldn’t have levered up as much as they did. Sorry. Maybe the new owners of the business will make necessary changes to run the business lean and not take out as many loans.
- gumby 7y agoWhy do you assume that your local restaurant or book shop has taken out many loans? It might simply be operating on a tiny margin. Plus it’s not unreasonable for someone setting up a restaurant to take out a loan for the initial fixtures and such as they will be intended to be amortized over several years.
- 0x8BADF00D 7y agoSure, that is fair. My point is that Bank of America itself would never extend loans to these businesses. It must mean there is some fundamental issue with the economics of the business. This is the same Bank of America that was expert in packaging dogshit BBB bonds. The fact that the latest stimulus bill enables these types of loans means a lot of these businesses that do not have a profitable business model will stay afloat. These are malinvestments enabled by the government. Shitty management will never be punished for their incompetence. Don't you want a world where incompetent managers are punished by the market for their incompetence? I certainly do.
- gumby 7y agoMany were probably running ok in steady state but will die due to all their customers vanishing (For endogenous reasons) unless something happens. And their employees will all become unemployed. It’s the ultimate in liquidity shocks and is an otherwise uninsurable risk excerpt if the whole economynis used in an attempt to fight it. If I took your attitude where should people live: not in California where earthquakes are more likely than the average, nor the Midwest where tornadoes are, nor near an ocean where storms could happen, nor mountains where landslides can happen.
- 7y ago
- mrfusion 7y agoI wish anyone would listen :-(
- sershe 7y agoThere's a saying in Russia, or rather a hope some opposition figures voiced, that one day "the fridge will beat the TV", i.e. the economic mismanagement and poor living conditions (the empty fridge) will overpower the TV (full of propaganda) and the people will become disillusioned with powers that be. Alas, so far it has never happened in Russia (the closest was probably 2011) - there's usually just enough money from the exports and more than enough propaganda. There's hope that the current situation will end when it becomes dire for millions of newly unemployed and bankrupt, and the fridge will too defeat the lockdown insanity.