6 ms·
Now, I don't think Zoom should have been advertising E2EE when it isn't. But I think some people are still missing the general point that E2EE is fundamentally
by crazygringo 7y ago
Now, I don't think Zoom should have been advertising E2EE when it isn't.
But I think some people are still missing the general point that E2EE is fundamentally incompatible with general-purpose business/educational videoconferencing.
It works for Facetime which is designed for small groups exclusively using a Facetime app.
But the second you allow phone dial-in (virtually always a hard requirement), the second you allow cloud recording (which the article acknowledges), E2EE becomes meaningless, because the server itself necessarily becomes another endpoint.
For >99.9% of people this is fine.
For the <0.1% who might be the hand-selected targets of government spying, industrial espionage, or crime enforcement, then no, you shouldn't be using Zoom. But if that's a top priority for you, you weren't already using Zoom anyways -- I assume you'd be using auditable open-source encryption. You wouldn't have trusted Zoom marketing terms in the first place.
- kardos 7y ago> The second you allow cloud recording (which the article acknowledges), E2EE becomes meaningless Not sure I agree with this one. Assuming a design where the server is just jockeying around encrypted streams because it doesn't have the keys, it could store the encrypted stream upon instructions from the client. The client would need to keep the key so it can retrieve and decrypt the recording later.
- khc 7y agooften time meetings are recorded so they can be played back later for people who didn't attend the meeting.
- jwr 7y ago> But the second you allow phone dial-in (virtually always a hard requirement) I'm really curious about this one — I've noticed that indeed in the US people tend to expect to be able to dial-in using the PSTN. Why would people do that? I haven't seen this happening much in Europe, and the Whereby (https://whereby.com/ https://whereby.com/) conferencing tool doesn't even offer dial-in, which isn't a problem. Why is dialing in using the PSTN a thing?
- detaro 7y agoBecause everyone has a phone pretty much everywhere, and knows how to use it. So its the ultimate fallback channel for people having computer issues, network issues, being on the move or in remote locations, ...
- pwinnski 7y agoI've participated in Zoom meetings while driving. I've participated in Zoom meetings while sitting in a conference room with a speakerphone of considerably higher quality than any laptop mic. The first case is probably unsafe. The second was very common back when we had offices with high-quality speakerphones.
- johannes1234321 7y agoDialing in via phone works for everybody, no app needed, no app to use etc. it works with all sorts of conf room setup and even the use case of "assistant sets up the phone call for the CEO and then transfers the call" works.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoNot using Zoom but I have one coworker with a new Dell laptop that won't properly detect headphone jack events. He has to dial in. I had the same problem but found a way to fix it. The Waves Maxx Audio tool which is apparently responsible for managing the hardware is useless junk.
- crazygringo 7y agoIn my experience at large corporations, it's mainly used when you're participating in the meeting from your cellphone, because you're on your way to the airport, on the train, in a hotel lobby, etc., but it's crucial they don't make a decision without you or that you hear all the details or correct misunderstandings. Obviously this is more common day-to-day for management/sales who are constantly traveling, than engineering. For whatever technological reason, cell phone calls tend to be far more reliable than internet calls. Especially if you're in a taxi or on a train, you may get so many dropped packets it's literally unusable. While an actual phone calls works perfectly fine. Not sure if it's how carriers prioritize traffic, or different technologies, or what. I'd be curious if anyone has the answer. I'm also not sure why this would be any different in Europe. (It's also, of course, the option of last resort when you can't get the damned app/microphone to work for whichever of a million reasons.)
- sly010 7y agoI think this is an important point not just in the context of Zoom, but every time privacy (or the lack of) gets thrown around in an argument. It's perfectly possible to have end to end encrypted email, text, payments etc, but: 1. You will always loose features. 2. The "endpoint" (you) becomes responsible for a much bigger part of the protocol. Most modern applied crypto is just shuffling trust and responsibility around.
- htfy96 7y agoA reasonable tradeoff could be a federated structure, where a local server in federation (school/corporate/...) acts as a trusted 3rd party.
- sneak 7y ago> For the <0.1% who might be the hand-selected targets of government spying The US government engages in bulk spying; this comment is a red herring. Without end to end cryptography, even normal, everyday people are at risk. This trivializes a very important issue.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- netsharc 7y agoSo basically, if you're comfortable having your business meeting in a crowded restaurant, then Zoom is an okay tool to use.
- atoav 7y agoI always think of encryption of a preventive thing. A bit like maintaining redundancy in hospitals and healthcare it might seem a bit cumbersome and overkill during calm times, but it has to be there once you need it. The similarities won't end there: encryption for everybody is needed just to protect the few really vulnerable ones. Encryption is directly linked to freedom in a society, because the lack of encryption acts as a power multiplier for those who are already in power, because it makes manipulating the masses easier even if single individuals are not at all hurt by it.
- scrumbledober 7y agowith the recent news of SpaceX banning Zoom [1] I wonder how many defense contractors or other organizations with high security clearances use Zoom. [1]: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-spacex-zoom-video-commn/elon-musks-spacex-bans-zoom-over-privacy-concerns-memo-idUSKBN21J71H https://www.reuters.com/article/us-spacex-zoom-video-commn/e...
- m3kw9 7y agoThe main concern with spacex was that it probably was not it administrated and employees were using it adhoc with no security audit oversight. With the other vector of attacks(zero days, email leak) that is why they stopped it.
- bad_user 7y agoI don't understand you. Being from Romania, in all the companies I worked on, we had the need to communicate online by voice and video (mostly with Americans and among ourselves), plus I tended to work in companies with a remote culture. The last time somebody needed to dial into a call I was in was ... 10 years ago. Given we have nearly unlimited 4G data plans for cheap and smartphones, being on the go isn't a problem either. Since when is this ability to dial-in such a hard requirement? > "For >99.9% of people this is fine." 99.9% of people don't understand what end-to-end encryption is and why it is needed, because they think their calls are secure, when in fact they aren't. It is actually our responsibility to make end-to-end encryption mainstream and to educate people.
- edmundsauto 7y agoI dial in to calls all the time. Frequently when driving / on public transport. Phone system is much more reliable.
- fossuser 7y agoLargely depends on business and culture (also Romania has abnormally good internet). Where I work nobody calls in and everyone uses webcams for VTC (software company, skews younger), but at my girlfriend's company a lot of people call in and nobody uses webcams.
- MatmaRex 7y agoIt was a surprise for me as well, but people in the US dial into meetings using their phone all the time. I don't understand it either.
- m12k 7y agoIt's like pagers, fax, checks and chip-less credit cards - Americans take a long time to abandon their legacy tech.
- djannzjkzxn 7y agoOften I’ve seen that the one person calling in the most senior person in the meeting, or anyone involved in sales. Someone who is traveling around to meet in person a lot. Often they are calling from the road or an airport. The mobile phone connection is more reliable than mobile data in these scenarios.
- Spooky23 7y agoI think they made a poor word choice in an effort to simplify the message while saying something less vague than "military grade encryption" or whatever. The transit legs of a Zoom meeting are TLS, which is what the customer cares about. Most of the vitriol about this issue is from a subset of security and IT people for whom E2EE is a term of art. In most any commercial service setting, E2EE is always going to be a bullshit term for someone.
- seemslegit 7y agoMaybe there should be a radio button upon installation that asks people whether they have something to hide and offers a special version with super good encryption for those who say yes.
- iknowstuff 7y agoYou could actually have an e2ee conference. Even with FaceTime you trust Apple to give you the users' private keys, and not MITM-ed ones. With a conference, the server could generate a private/public key pair for each dialed-in phone number. That way you could retain hope that they were giving you non-MITM-ed keys for participants when no phones are involved. Generally though, Apple's "end-to-end encryption" is a false promise and SHOULD NOT be trusted. If they wanted to provide privacy and weren't bound by the government (like they were when they tried to encrypt backups), they'd follow whatsapp and allow offline comparison of keys via QR codes and notify of changes. But they didn't. Apple won the marketing battle on privacy, but please don't trust them. They have access to all backups, all your pictures, and they can MITM your iMessage/FaceTime when the government requests it (or whenever they want to, really).
- ummonk 7y agoRight, but I'd also say that where E2EE is not available, there is a strong incentive for companies to go with something self-hosted rather than SaaS.
- ubercow13 7y agoPlenty of companies seem fine with storing all their communications on Slack's servers, storing all their IP on Github's servers, storing all their data in Office 365, all their confidential email in GSuite etc. Why is Zoom so different? There is some subset of organisations for which none of these things are acceptable of course.
- toddmorey 7y agoZoom made a lot of features like passwordless meeting links and join-by-phone the default, most likely to help with early adoption. Now they are working on making them optional and even making some runnable on-prem. I think thats fine if you let users opt in and clearly explain the tradeoffs. But it was risky to make so many security tradeoffs in the name of ease-of-use. Somebody at Zoom has the fundamental belief that these services are over complicated but lacks the empathy of having been a victim of a major hack.
- solinent 7y ago> But the second you allow phone dial-in (virtually always a hard requirement), the second you allow cloud recording (which the article acknowledges), E2EE becomes meaningless, because the server itself necessarily becomes another endpoint. This isn't true if one of the involved parties hosts their own video server. With jitsi I found it tremendously easy to set up a server.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]