5 ms·
I was looking at this SBA loan forgiveness plan that's a part of the relief / recovery / bailout bill. I actually think right now is an incredible time to launc
by echelon 7y ago
I was looking at this SBA loan forgiveness plan that's a part of the relief / recovery / bailout bill. I actually think right now is an incredible time to launch a startup, and I want to hire a few out of work software engineers to work with me.
My plan was to incorporate, take out a loan, and pay payroll with the entirety of it. Unfortunately it looks like the bill requires you to have been in business before February 15th with verifiable employees on payroll.
I'm really miffed, because putting unemployed employees on payroll at a new company isn't any worse than keeping existing employees on payroll at a business that doesn't have customers. In fact, if a new company is more productive and is working on solving problems that arise because of this virus, it seems more productive to solve the new problems than to keep the unviable businesses running.
I'll have to figure something else out...
- edoceo 7y agoA new business is far riskier than keeping an existing one. You seem to have forgotten the need for prroven product-market fit.
- vb6sp6 7y agoits a program to keep business afloat, not launch new ones.
- fphhotchips 7y agoYeah, but GP has a point; from a total employment standpoint, there is no difference. In fact encouraging new business at this time could create a burst of new, lean, innovative startups solving real problems from a time of hardship, rather than fake problems from a time of prosperity.
- gamblor956 7y agoThere are existing startup incentive programs... The point of CARES is to keep existing revenue-generating businesses open, and their employees paid. And quite frankly, as a former techie it's kind of disgusting that people in the tech community are complaining that their employee-free, revenue-free, 1-day-old startup doesn't qualify for a program intended to keep existing, otherwise viable businesses (absent COVID19) running and their employees paid. This is not the time for the tech community to launch yet another regulatory arbitrage startup that exploits everyone else.
- echelon 7y ago> employee-free I want to hire people. I'm probably still going to do this, but dip into my savings to do so.
- vb6sp6 7y ago> from a total employment standpoint, there is no difference There are huge differences. The obvious, but unstated, difference is the existing network of businesses that already work together.
- ska 7y agoIt's probably overly simplistic to treat jobs as fungible that way. Efforts to keep existing companies intact make sense. Efforts to encourage support creating new ones do too - but they aren't the same effort as they aren't the same effect (notwithstanding OP's contention that they are).
- perl4ever 7y agoIf we are spending billions or trillions on keeping existing companies intact, surely it's because letting them fail and then rebuilding would be more expensive. If it made sense to just start new businesses, then we wouldn't even be trying to save the old ones.
- lgleason 7y agoWhile the government is shoveling money out the back of a truck right now to try to keep the economy afloat even they, IMHO rightly, have limits right now. This is to keep established businesses such as restaurants, small manufacturers etc. alive, not to fund risky startups.
- blihp 7y agoYou'll have a better shot at new business grants/loans on the other side of this when they're looking to do stimulus. Right now, they're just trying to minimize the amount of implosions with existing businesses.
- perl4ever 7y agoIt costs money to set up a business, plus it's risky. Doesn't make sense to encourage that now. The whole point of giving people money is so that they don't have to recreate existing businesses when things are more normal.
- _curious_ 7y agoSounds like you were basically just going to start a company on the basis of a government handout, well okay. Surely you can see how your "idea" is susceptible to fraud and why they have some requirements for qualifications. Additionally, it's LIKELY that the company which was already established had product/market fit, proven tangible value, and paying customers. It's UNLIKELY that your "startup" will/would...especially if you're the type of person who would exploit such situation as you describe above.