5 ms·
>> If enough people who suddenly found themselves without a sense of smell self-reported their condition, you might well create an early warning signal that tol
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
>> If enough people who suddenly found themselves without a sense of smell self-reported their condition, you might well create an early warning signal that told you where the virus was heading, and how fast.
I am skeptical. A test based on the sense of smell would have a very high amount of noise. There is no good, concrete measure of a person's sense of smell. One has to ask the person to get a "measurment" and it's very hard to know what different people would mean by "I can smell fine" or "I can't smell as well as I used to".
Maybe some people would convince themselves they have no sense of smell (like some people convince themselves they are gluten or lactose "intolerant"). Maybe some people who have a weak sense of smell anyway (because they smoke or live in places with a high level of air pollution) would tend to ignore having completely lost their smell.
In any case, it would be very hard to track real infections with such an unreliable measure.
- pen2l 7y agoI’m covid19-positive and I don’t have any impairment in my ability to smell nor do I recall having such impairment in recent time. The most salient symptoms for me have been GI problems.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- akavel 7y ago"[The doctors] concluded that roughly 80% of the people who lost their sense of smell would test positive for the coronavirus, and that somewhere between 30% and 60% of those who had tested positive for the virus had also lost their sense of smell." covid19? --> ~30-60% chance of loss of smell loss of smell? --> ~80% chance of covid19 [in the data they collected]
- nitrogen 7y agoOther things can cause loss of sense of smell too, long before covid19, so it would have to be way more prevalent in covid than any other cause for that 80% to make sense. If so, that's interesting.
- gnulinux 7y agoIs this loss of sense of smell permanent? That sounds very scary.
- wollstonecraft 7y agoOlfactory neurons are somewhat notable for their ability to regenerate.
- gnulinux 7y agoDoes the virus damage olfactory neurons, or does it cause loss of smell via different mechanism? For what it's worth, my grandma lost her sense of smell permanently in her 30s after a car crash. Unfortunately, now she can't tell if the food is burning.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gentleman11 7y agoInteresting. I didn’t know GI symptoms were significant until now https://labblog.uofmhealth.org/lab-report/are-digestive-issues-a-symptom-of-covid-19 https://labblog.uofmhealth.org/lab-report/are-digestive-issu...
- baq 7y agonoisy channels have information capacity. reports are that the loss of sense of smell and taste are severe, sometimes total. things 'taste weird' or have no taste at all. it doesn't matter what the person's sense of smell was before - the magnitude of change reported by a noticeable amount of individuals in a geotemporal cluster is enough to trigger an alert. the key is 'noticeable amount', so you measure background noise first.
- drewzero1 7y agoYour point about the fallibility of self-reporting sense of smell is valid, but please don't talk about real and serious food sensitivities in such a flippant way. They aren't subjective in the same way as smell, and there are medical tests available and widely used to verify intolerances (such as the hydrogen breath test for lactose intolerance, or the intestinal biopsy for Celiac disease). For testing by sense of smell to work with any degree of certainty, there would have to be similar tests beyond self-reporting.
- gvjddbnvdrbv 7y agoThere are plenty of people with real allergies and real intolerances. There are also plenty of people who don't have any allergy or intolerance and convince themselves they do. Those people make it harder for those that have real allergies and intolerances.
- hkeide 7y agoHow?
- kharms 7y agoAlternatively, they are people that pay attention to their bodies and have intolerances that aren't strong enough to warrant a medical diagnosis but still make them feel shitty. I'm also skeptical of the idea that they make it harder for people with "real" intolerances - in the gluten example, there's been an explosion of GF foods, products, and menu signage ever since "gluten intolerance" became a familiar phrase.
- drewzero1 7y agoTo me it seems like the main way they "make it harder" is that _other people_ like to talk about them a lot and might be inclined to take intolerances in general (including diagnosed ones) less seriously. Which I don't really understand -- it doesn't hurt me for someone else to avoid eating something, why should I fault them for that?
- 7y ago
- amscanne 7y ago> I am skeptical. A test based on the sense of smell would have a very high amount of noise. There is no good, concrete measure of a person's sense of smell. Parents with young children in diapers might disagree. I can think of one test that occurs consistently and is easy to validate. (Joking aside, I do think about the fact that I can detect soiled diapers as evidence that I can still smell just fine!)