5 ms·
This is why I have a piece of tape over my webcam. I really don’t need a webcam on my MacBook at all. Kinda like I don’t need a microphone on my TV. Why are
by mulmen 7y ago
This is why I have a piece of tape over my webcam.
I really don’t need a webcam on my MacBook at all. Kinda like I don’t need a microphone on my TV. Why are these not optional on devices? How do we know this is really what consumers want?
It feels like a lesson from the “you can have any color as long as it’s black” school of consumer choice.
- timwis 7y agoBut what about the microphone?
- mulmen 7y agoI don’t have an easy (non-destructive) fix for that one and I actually do voice chats with my laptop. I’d feel better about a real hardware switch for both or a separate device. Sadly that doesn’t seem to be an option.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoThere's external microphones with an on/off switch; of course, if you can't tell Mac to never use the builtin microphone it's probably neither here nor there.
- mulmen 7y agoWell the benefit of an external device is I can unplug it and put it in a drawer :) The problem is I can’t confidently defeat the builtin devices. I would be more comfortable if they just didn’t exist.
- kylec 7y agoAnd what about all your data? (photos, emails, texts, browsing history, passwords, etc) If an attacker has compromised my computer to such an extent that they’s be able to record me, I’d be more worried about access to my private data than I am about being photographed through the webcam.
- spockz 7y agoWell, as this case shows, an attacker doesn’t always need to get low level access to your device in order to capture video and audio. So there is still a valid concern shot being recorded.
- scalio 7y agoYou can open the macbook and unplug the camera and mic connectors from the mainboard.
- mulmen 7y agoNeat. Can I put a switch inline? Without setting myself on fire?
- karolist 7y agoYou could whip up a quick script to move driver kexts for mic and camera in and out of extensions folder essentially toggling the functionality. This would require a reboot though.
- saagarjha 7y agoThis would also require disabling System Integrity Protection.
- martin_a 7y agoIn times when you can't upgrade the RAM anymore after you bought it? I doubt it sadly.
- SamuelAdams 7y agoIt's actually getting worse. The 2020 macbook air has soldered secondary storage. In a day when NVME drives are as tiny as ever. So now if you want to upgrade from 256 GB to 1 TB you need to buy an entirely new board.
- martin_a 7y agoI'm not sure, but hasn't it been like this since... 2018 or so? I thought all after-market upgrade possibilites were gone, because they started soldering the RAM and everthing else. Didn't knew you could upgrade any storage at all.
- wensley 7y agoYou can order a new ThinkPad with the option of no camera or microphone.
- est31 7y agoThe one I bought recently has a tiny movable plastic shutter built into the device. Helps with the camera at least.
- LeonM 7y agoFWIW thinkpads have a function key on the keyboard to mute the microphone. With indicator LED. I don't know how it is implemented, may be in software, may be done in firmware. It won't be perfect but at least it gives you a visual indication that your mic is (or should be) muted.
- mulmen 7y agoReally? That’s kinda neat. Can you still get premium (MBP level) hardware or are those basic models?
- Reason077 7y ago> ”I really don’t need a webcam ... Why are these not optional on devices?” The webcam is cheap enough that the cost to make it optional (ie: added manufacturing and logistical complexity of another model variant) would greatly exceed the cost of the part. Most people (except some high security military/intelligence customers, perhaps) aren’t willing to pay more to not have a webcam.
- mulmen 7y agoYou’re right of course. I’m still uncomfortable with the number of cameras and microphones that found their way into my home. Especially for how rarely I use them. I don’t feel like my life is much better with them around.
- Razengan 7y agoThen tape/break them.
- ht85 7y agoI'm not sure about smartphones but it seems like a physical cover would be a perfect fit on a notebook. Maybe the reason it isn't done is that it gives bad vibes to people about being spied on without their knowledge?
- tinus_hn 7y agoMany modern laptops now come with a physical lid you can manually slide over the camera. The reason this isn’t being done more is because of course this leads to people wondering why their camera doesn’t work when the lid is on.
- lotsofpulp 7y ago> Why are these not optional on devices? Because according to the seller’s analysis, the probability of marginal profit is not sufficient. >How do we know this is really what consumers want? “We” don’t, and short of a worldwide poll, one can only guess. The seller, especially as one of the most profitable entities in the world, is presumed to be able to come up with decent market analysis.
- scalio 7y agoAs I said below, and without knowing if this is applicable to all models, mic and camera can be physically disconnected from the mainboard.
- m463 7y agoPurism laptops come with a hardware switches for camera/mic and bt/wifi. (though the switch isn't labeled as to which direction is on and which is off, which might have changed in current models)
- mulmen 7y agoHaha that’s amazing. Finally someone gives us what we are asking for and it still doesn’t work!
- m463 7y agono it works (flip the switch and the USB device disappears). but on and off should be labeled.
- test1235 7y agomy thinkpad has a switch which amounts to a cover over the lens ... dunno why it'd need to be any more complicated that this.
- SamuelAdams 7y agoAlso Thinkpad laptops are starting to ship with a "think shutter" thing which is essentially a hardware switch for the webcam.
- pixelrevision 7y agoA physical off switch for both would also be a great option.