This ignores friction of money entirely. Let's truck fuel to the far ends of the empire only to truck it back. Plus, giving to all dilutes the value of the fu

This ignores friction of money entirely. Let's truck fuel to the far ends of the empire only to truck it back. Plus, giving to all dilutes the value of the fund and concentrates wealth back into the hands of the affluent over time. "Money is commutative" nope money ain't math, ten dollars passed ten times among ten friends is $100 of GDP, that is not commutativity.