5 ms·
> Our wild history is presented as a time before the world was scarred by borders, before politics, before race, before even the concept of identity carved out
by cortesoft 7y ago
> Our wild history is presented as a time before the world was scarred by borders, before politics, before race, before even the concept of identity carved out its demarcations of who belongs and where.
This is just flat wrong. Tribal politics are brutal, and any ancient community would have a very strong sense of identity, and about who belonged and who didn't. Life was way harder for people who didn't fit into the role assigned by their tribe; if you didn't conform, and were kicked out, you would die.
- armenarmen 7y agoThis. The names of many tribes is simply "the people" in their language. You can easily read into it that those humans not that are not members of their tribe are not people. http://www.native-languages.org/original.htm http://www.native-languages.org/original.htm
- natmaka 7y agoWe invented huge anonymous cities where either tight surveillance or gang wars flourish, extermination camps, total war and many other wonders. Let's explain to any tribe that we, 'people', painfully devised and realized ways to massively and indiscriminately kill very remote civilians using dedicated complex machinery (ICBMs), then discuss about who is 'people' for who. Comparing the 'costs' of nearly-constant but limited tribal violence to our own 'civilized' violence isn't easy.
- cortesoft 7y agoThey are the exact same thing. We have just transplanted those tribal aspects to our modern world, but we still are the same people.
- natmaka 7y agoIndeed. Therefore the "outsiders aren't real people" stance isn't specific to tribal life. Upon reading (above) "Tribal politics are brutal" and "Life was way harder" one may think about the way we wage war, establish the rat race in huge cities, try hard to control everything everywhere to the point of practically barring anyone to opt out... "brutal"? "harder"? Doubt so.
- icebraining 7y ago> Therefore the "outsiders aren't real people" stance isn't specific to tribal life. Nobody said it is.
- natmaka 7y agoPlease read "armenarmen" comment, above: "those humans not that are not members of their tribe are not people". Albeit difficult to grok, it seems pretty clear to me.
- icebraining 7y agoarmenarmen said that happens in tribal life; but not that it was unique/specific to tribal life.
- natmaka 7y agoThat's not my understanding, as he answered "This." to a post containing "Tribal politics are brutal, and any ancient community would have a very strong sense of identity, and about who belonged and who didn't. Life was way harder...".
- michaelmrose 7y agoIt's not easy but it's been contemplated. https://ourworldindata.org/ethnographic-and-archaeological-evidence-on-violent-deaths https://ourworldindata.org/ethnographic-and-archaeological-e...
- danharaj 7y agoThere is evidence that hunter gatherers would take care of extremely disabled people. What do you mean by "didn't fit into the role assigned by their tribe"? What are some references on the body of knowledge you are confidently referring to?
- cortesoft 7y agoJust meaning that if you didn't conform to the tribe's rules, you would be exiled... and exile meant death. Being part of the community mattered way more in tribal society than modern society. That also means the tribe was close knit, and would take care of sick and disabled members... as long as you followed the rules.
- natmaka 7y agoIn a tribal zone exile doesn't everywhere nor always imply death. We nearly cannot escape from our societies. Is it better to be able to escape or not? For the ones really loving liberty the choice seems pretty clear. In every human society one has to apparently submit to some rules. It is somewhat difficult for me to believe that I enjoy more freedom 'Lynx' (the woman subject of the article).
- icebraining 7y agoCan't we escape? What is preventing you from doing what Lynx did, right now?
- lonelappde 7y agoI'd have to turn off Reddit and go outside. More seriously, I'd need start a competing tourism business to pay my bills.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoRight now we'd have to be allowed outside
- Thorentis 7y agoCame here to say this. This writer is clearly projecting her own opinion of what an ideal society looks like into the past. People usually do this as a way to convince people of why their world view is correct ("this is how people used to do it!"). In this case though, it is blatantly wrong.
- staz 7y agoYes it's the myth of the Noble Savage all over again
- blaser-waffle 7y agoAgreed. Most of these ancient societies would be completely alien to us. Even pre-US Civil War would be different enough to make the average USA-ian uncomfortable.