5 ms·
I'm not a fan of Zoom... But the pile-on of grief is ridiculous. The "war dialing" issue is a great example. Webex has had the exact same "flaw" for a decade,
by Spooky23 7y ago
I'm not a fan of Zoom... But the pile-on of grief is ridiculous.
The "war dialing" issue is a great example. Webex has had the exact same "flaw" for a decade, with the exact same solution - set a meeting password. Other solutions like Google Meet or Skype have the "lobby" approach.
- somethoughts 7y agoFun fact - perhaps not widely known and perhaps why it shares a similar philosophy as Webex: Zoom was founded in 2011 by Eric Yuan, a lead engineer from Cisco Systems and its collaboration business unit WebEx.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoom_Video_Communications#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoom_Video_Communications#Hist...
- albertshin 7y agoI've always wondered about spinoff startups like this from larger companies: aren't there usually non competes that would prevent them starting them?
- reaperducer 7y agoThey're not usually infinite. My father waited one out for three years, then went back into the industry for a rival firm and put his old boss out of business.
- andrewfong 7y agoThey're generally not enforceable in California, provided you're not making use of any protected IP or what not. https://casetext.com/statute/california-codes/california-business-and-professions-code/division-7-general-business-regulations/part-2-preservation-and-regulation-of-competition/chapter-1-contracts-in-restraint-of-trade/section-16600-void-contracts/analysis?PHONE_NUMBER_GROUP=P&citingPage=1&sort=relevance https://casetext.com/statute/california-codes/california-bus...
- teraflop 7y agoIMO, when it comes to security, the fact that other people have made the same mistake makes a design flaw more egregious, not less.
- tptacek 7y agoThat is absolutely not an information security norm. Most security mistakes fall into common patterns.
- Spooky23 7y agoIt’s not an egregious flaw, any more than the telephone numbering system is. It’s a design decision to improve usability that is generating a lot of noise during an extraordinary period. Usability is the zoom priority, and the reason why people who already own more secure, no cost, solutions like Teams, Skype or Google Meet buy Zoom.
- filleduchaos 7y agoKnowing someone's phone number very obviously doesn't grant you direct access to autojoin their calls with people. At _best_ you can attempt to tell if they're currently in a call or not by calling them, but even that is far from reliable (e.g. in places where voicemail isn't as much of a thing do not disturb is sometimes implemented by pretending to be busy or switched off)
- apple4ever 7y agoPeople often forgot that its a Security-Usabilty scale, with perfect security on one side and perfect usability on the other. An unplugged computer is perfectly secure, while a computer wide open is perfectly usable. But neither is usually preferable. As with most things, its a trade off.
- ehsankia 7y agoIsn't it easily fixed by making IDs slightly higher entropy, and also rate limiting retries? Something like a Youtube ID which is 11-char in Base62, which is short enough but has so much entropy that even know with billions of videos, entering a random ID will most likely not work. You should also always have some reasonable rate limit of any sort of API query, if someone is querying rooms at 10qps or more, there's clearly something wrong.
- boardwaalk 7y agoI wouldn't be shy about betting the reason they haven't done this is because they don't want the ids to be longer/have a larger character set than they have to be, because they'd take longer/be more error prone to type/say out loud. Lowest possible friction: the reason for most of their flaws thus far.
- wazanator 7y agoA phone number is already 10 digits. As long as you put proper break characters between the groupings it's not hard to read IMO.
- govg 7y agoThey could also just generate 4 words and string them together as the password. Considerably more entropy than 10 digital and easier to communicate too.
- ajmurmann 7y agoZoom in fact also allows you to enable a "waiting room" for all meetings owned by your account. It's not always ideal though. I've organized meetings with 10+ people, want able to attend the meeting and now nobody can join the session.
- solstice 7y agoI'm not sure about this, but there is a way to make someone a co-host who could then presumably make those decisions?