2 ms·
Nope. You can't claim it's increased demand for consumer varieties under these conditions. Such increased demand of TP would see a fairly smooth increase in p
by ineedasername 7y ago
Nope. You can't claim it's increased demand for consumer
varieties under these conditions. Such increased demand of TP would see a fairly smooth increase in purchase & usage patterns as people ran out of their current supply and purchased their normal replenishment slightly more often. That's not the behavior we've seen. Indeed, if it had been that behavioral pattern, then the modest elasticity in production capacity (roughly 20% IIRC from manufacturers) would have been enough to smooth over the issue during the time necessary to ramp up further and perhaps repurpose commercial lines for consumer packaging.
That isn't what happened. Near me, it literally disappeared overnight about 3-4 weeks ago, and hasn't come back since.
- FrojoS 7y agoI don't know one way or the other but I wouldn't be as sure as you are. Like others have said here, its probably a combination of many things, including a bit of a panic, but its an interesting analysis for sure. Yes, there was a bit of a 'bank run' effect. But it wasn't as huge as one might think. I saw some numbers for Germany from Spiegel.de and sales of toilet paper went up by 'only' ~100% (compared to 700% for hand sanitizer) [1]. Compared to the out-of-need increase of ~40% that is cited in the article here, that's not as huge a difference as I had assumed. If you assume that rational people are forward looking and are slightly stocking up with out panicking. Once there was an obvious shortage, people might have panicked a bit. But not for no reason. Here in Switzerland, the sewer system did get clogged up by toilette paper alternatives like wet wipes and cotton [2]. So it seems, that indeed some people ran out of toilet paper. Of course they should have used water instead. But it shows, that our just-in-time, high efficiency economy is very fragile, even without mass irrationality and panic. [1] I couldn't find today's source from a quick google search. But another article cites a 200% increase https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/corona-krise-nachfrage-nach-desinfektionsmittel-verachtfacht-sich-a-7befcedb-a1ee-4342-8bd7-bc5f8c8e59ec https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/corona-krise-nachfrage-nac... , I assume the 100% was for the whole of March [2] https://www.20min.ch/schweiz/news/story/Feuchttuecher-bedrohen-die-Abwassersysteme-23998381 https://www.20min.ch/schweiz/news/story/Feuchttuecher-bedroh...
- ineedasername 7y agoI didn't say there wasn't some element of increased demand due to more home use, I was responding to the article's assertion that nearly all of the shortage was a result of that.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]