3 ms·
...aren't these all problems that emails have too, in more-or-less equal measure? Of course, Slack needs to be better than email, or there's no point—but I'd p
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
...aren't these all problems that emails have too, in more-or-less equal measure?
Of course, Slack needs to be better than email, or there's no point—but I'd posit that it already is, despite being unable to address these problems. The overall interface of a "chatroom" just works better for quick conversations compared to long email chains. Maybe not much better, but better.
As I see it, the problems pointed out in this article are the eternal problems of all communication within a large group—including face-to-face. It's why small companies can be more nimble despite less resources, and why managing the size of a team is so important.
And while the author's suggestions are great in theory, I can't imagine how you'd even go about implementing them. At least, not until AI gets much, much better than it is today.
- jasonv 7y agoI think I'm officially bored of the "Slack is a problem" threads. Just spent time in a dev org where 500+ members of a technical team used email, Teams & Slack. However you want to slice it, there are organizational habits of a department that large, and nothing deep in a licensed product stack is likely to fix/influence how a big dept runs itself. They superficially used all the enterprise tools at their disposal, because relying on implementations complicated enough to need documentation wouldn't live long in a big org that had lots of turnover (how's your Sharepoint doing?). Said team had people at all levels who were unreachable in any way, except when you slacked them. You disrupted them, told them they'd ignored an email that you really needed a response to, and they gave you what you needed. Slack fixed the "I'm ignoring my inbox and I have 40K unread emails in there" problem that feels typical in enterprises. Teams worked to connect tech and non-tech business units. It helped to keep business teams off Slack. Slack was noisy for the ops team. How Slack is supposed to "fix" disorganized, i-don't-care-about-management principles of big departments is beyond me. The flip side: the business thrived, everyone worked pretty sane house, and the paychecks arrived every other week without fail. There was a lot to complain about, but no one ever complained about Slack (or even Teams).
- SahAssar 7y agoYou're saying that email was overloaded so people turned to slack instead? People can change how notifications are handled for email too, so that is not at all new and I think that changing communications to a proprietary protocol instead of configuring an email client is stupid.
- jasonv 7y agoYeah, sure. And I usually build up a set of filters and rules so that my inbox is manageable, but I think the compassionate point of view is that email is loaded with more disposable and management heavy communications than slack tends to be. Slack was where work got done. Email, less so.
- SahAssar 7y ago> email is loaded with more disposable and management heavy communications That's a cultural problem, not a technical one. Slack gets work done just because the bad practices haven't migrated to it yet, not because it's a better communication medium. In some spaces the email bad practices have migrated to slack too and personally I have to ignore slack just as much as email because of that.
- kristianc 7y ago> Slack gets work done just because the bad practices haven't migrated to it yet, not because it's a better communication medium. Well no solution can possibly compete with all the bad things that _might_ happen on it in 10 years time.
- andrewprock 7y agoI have seen plenty of bad practices in slack. In particular, there is more and more of a tendency to treat slack as "publication of record" as opposed to "ephemeral missives".
- visarga 7y ago
- marmaduke 7y ago> At least, not until AI gets much, much better than it is today. One could extend LDA (a common topic model) to include people, by modeling topics as mixtures of people (which they kinda are), and any given comment is generated by a mixture of topics. If anyone is missing, pull them in; if it's the wrong topic channel, move the thread over etc. I'm not saying it'd be compelling but it's possible